The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Back to the stores

Citarella Upper West Side

Upper West Side · Gourmet market

2135 Broadway, Upper West Side, Manhattan

On our list473

Herbs & fresh produce8 · 8
Pastes, sauces & condiments26 · 26
A.1. SauceUsually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Artichoke pasteUsually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Calabrian chilies (whole)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Chili crisp (classic: Lao Gan Ma, Fly By Jing...)Usually has it · $16.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Chili oilUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Chipotles in adoboUsually has it · $4.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Coconut aminosUsually has it · $19.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Dijon & French mustards (plain)Usually has it · $9.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Dijon & French mustards (whole grain)Usually has it · $9.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Duck sauceUsually has it · $5.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fish sauce (phuquoc)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Fish sauce (vegan)Usually has it · $37.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Harissa (classic)Usually has it · $9.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Hoisin sauceUsually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Kewpie mayo (US-made)Usually has it · $9.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Melinda's (Original Habanero (Hot, Extra Hot, XXXtra Hot))Usually has it · $5.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Miso (red)Usually has it · $13.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Miso (white)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Oyster sauce (vegetarian)Usually has it · $12.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Soy sauce (all-purpose)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Soy sauce (low-sodium)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
TahiniUsually has it · $12.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Teriyaki sauceUsually has it · $8.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Truff (Hotter Sauce)Usually has it · $24.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Truff (Original (black truffle))Usually has it · $24.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Turkish pepper paste (mild)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Spices & seasonings23 · 23
Allspice (ground)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Cardamom (green)Usually has it · $12.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Cinnamon (Vietnamese, ground)Usually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
ClovesUsually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Coriander seeds (ground)Usually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Everything bagel seasoningUsually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fennel seedsUsually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Flaky sea saltUsually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fleur de selUsually has it · $13.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Green peppercornsUsually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Hawaiian salt (black lava)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Herbes de ProvenceUsually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Himalayan pink saltUsually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Hungarian paprika (sweet)Usually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Kosher saltUsually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Nutmeg (whole)Usually has it · $9.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Nutritional yeastUsually has it · $10.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Peri-peri (sauce)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
SaffronUsually has it · $9.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Tasmanian pepperberryUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Truffle saltUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Vanilla beansUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
White pepper (ground)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Chiles5 · 5
Dried goods3 · 3
Tofu & plant proteins1 · 1
Pickles & ferments12 · 12
Fish & seafood40 · 40
Anchovies (paste)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
BarramundiUsually has it · $11.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Black codUsually has it · $44.99 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Caviar (kaluga)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Caviar (osetra)Usually has it · $201.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Caviar (white sturgeon)Usually has it · $113.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Clams (cherrystones)Usually has it · $1.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Clams (littlenecks)Usually has it · $1.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Clams (Manila clams)Usually has it · $11.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
CocklesUsually has it · $11.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Crab meat (lump, jumbo lump or backfin)Usually has it · $79.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Dover soleUsually has it · $51.74 each ($57.49/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
FlounderUsually has it · $34.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh oysters (live, in the shell)Usually has it · $2.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh oysters (shucked, fresh or frozen)Usually has it · $3.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh razor clamsUsually has it · $17.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh sardinesUsually has it · $19.99 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh scallops (Peconic or Nantucket bay scallops)Usually has it · $91.99 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh scallops (sea scallops)Usually has it · $56.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fresh squidUsually has it · $17.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Gilt-head breamUsually has it · $17.24 each ($11.49/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
Grouper (fresh or live)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
HalibutUsually has it · $45.99 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Herring (soused, in wine, vinegar or cream)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
King crab (legs and clusters, cooked and frozen)Usually has it · $171.49 each ($171.49/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
Lobster (live or whole cooked)Usually has it · $62.98 each ($31.49/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
Lobster (tails)Usually has it · $25.30 each ($57.49/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
Mussels (live, in the shell)Usually has it · $9.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Octopus (whole or legs, fresh or frozen)Usually has it · $28.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Rainbow troutUsually has it · $11.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Salt codUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
ScupUsually has it · $15.73 each ($6.99/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
Smoked troutUsually has it · $12.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Squid inkUsually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Stone crab (claws)Usually has it · $91.99 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
SwordfishUsually has it · $23.19 each ($28.99/LB) · checked Nov 17, 2026
TaramasalataUsually has it · $11.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Tinned salmon (plain, red or pink)Usually has it · $12.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Tinned tuna bellyUsually has it · $16.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Uni (roe (trays or packs))Usually has it · $50.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Pantry34 · 34
BliniUsually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Champagne vinegarUsually has it · $13.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Chestnuts (whole, roasted, peeled)Usually has it · $16.49 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Coconut milkUsually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Coconut sugarUsually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Comb honeyUsually has it · $29.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Corbarino tomatoesUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Dark brown sugarUsually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Demi-glace (concentrate, tub or frozen)Usually has it · $11.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Desiccated coconut (desiccated, unsweetened)Usually has it · $7.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Duck fatUsually has it · $21.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Falafel (dry mix)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Filo pastryUsually has it · $9.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Frozen soup dumplingsUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
GheeUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Hawaiian sweet rollsUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Hot honeyUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Macadamia nutsUsually has it · $22.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
MentsuyuUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
MirinUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Muscovado sugarUsually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Pistachio (pure paste)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Pistachio (sweet cream)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Rice vinegarUsually has it · $6.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
SabaUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
SchmaltzUsually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Sherry vinegarUsually has it · $16.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Sourdough starter (dried)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Speculaas (Biscoff)Usually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Sugar substitutes (monk fruit)Usually has it · $17.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Sugar substitutes (stevia)Usually has it · $7.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Tallow (beef)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Toasted sesame oilUsually has it · $20.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Truffle oilUsually has it · $18.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Flours & baking11 · 11
Snacks, sweets & convenience8 · 8
Meat, eggs & dairy7 · 7
Cheese7 · 7
Drinks & bar11 · 11
Beer & cider16 · 16
Noodles & pasta25 · 25
Bucatini (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Capellini (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Casarecce (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Cavatelli (dried)Usually has it · $9.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Egg noodles (dried)Usually has it · $5.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Farfalle (dried)Usually has it · $13.99 per lb · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fettuccine (dried)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fregola (dried)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Fusilli (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Gluten-free & legume pasta (Chickpea, lentil & bean)Usually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Gluten-free & legume pasta (Rice & corn)Usually has it · $8.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Lasagne (dried)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Linguine (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Mezzi rigatoni (dried)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Orecchiette (dried)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Orzo (dried)Usually has it · $14.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Paccheri (dried)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Pappardelle (dried)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Penne (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Rice sticks (dried)Usually has it · checked Nov 21, 2026
Rigatoni (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Soba (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Spaghetti (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Tagliatelle (dried)Usually has it · $10.49 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Udon (dried)Usually has it · $6.99 each · checked Nov 17, 2026
Rice, grains & pulses13 · 13

And 223 more ingredients.

It might also carry 27 more ingredients on our list (a guess from the kind of store, not confirmed).

Green means a recent sighting by a visitor or the store's own site showing it in stock. Yellow means a guide or catalog says they sometimes carry it, or a visitor says it's there some of the time. Orange: it's in the chain's catalog, this branch not checked.

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there