The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Back to the index
Sheep’s milk yogurt

Meat, eggs & dairy

Sheep’s milk yogurt

Stores that usually have Sheep’s milk yogurt: A Matter of Health (Nanuet, NY), Amagansett IGA (Amagansett, NY), Austin Organic Market (Forest Hills, Queens) and 153 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 28 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.

Also sold as sheep milk yogurt, sheep yogurt, sheep yoghurt, sheep’s yogurt, ewe’s milk yogurt, Old Chatham yogurt.

Substitute Greek yogurt or plain whole-milk yogurt.

Where to find it269 stores

  • A Matter of Health

    Usually has it$5.99Nanuet
    138 Rockland Plz · Nanuet
    A Matter of Health's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 14, 2026
  • A Matter of Health

    Usually has it$5.99Upper East Side
    1347 1st Ave · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    A Matter of Health's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 14, 2026
  • Amagansett IGA

    Usually has itAmagansett
    511 Montauk Hwy · Amagansett
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Amish Market (Amish Fine Food)

    Usually has it$7.45 eachHell's Kitchen
    731 9th Ave · Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan
    Amish Market on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Austin Organic Market

    Usually has itForest Hills
    72-48 Austin St · Forest Hills, Queens
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Balady Market

    Usually has itBay Ridge
    7128 5th Ave · Bay Ridge, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Basil Bandwagon Natural Market

    Usually has it$8.99Clinton
    38 Old Hwy 22 · Clinton
    Basil Bandwagon's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Basil Bandwagon Natural Market

    Usually has it$8.99Flemington
    276 Hwy 202/31 North · Flemington
    Basil Bandwagon's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Bishop's Orchards

    Usually has it2 productsGuilford
    1355 Boston Post Rd · Guilford
    Bishop's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Brooklyn Fare Downtown Brooklyn

    Usually has it6.99Downtown Brooklyn
    200 Schermerhorn St · Downtown Brooklyn, Brooklyn
    SwiftBurst shelf prices · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Brooklyn Fare Hudson Yards

    Usually has it6.99Hell's Kitchen
    431 W 37th St · Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan
    SwiftBurst shelf prices · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Brooklyn Fare West End Ave

    Usually has it$4.39Upper West Side
    75 West End Avenue · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Brooklyn Fare West Village

    Usually has it6.99West Village
    666 Greenwich Street · West Village, Manhattan
    SwiftBurst shelf prices · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Butterfield Market Lexington Ave

    Usually has it2 productsUpper East Side
    1114 Lexington Ave · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Butterfield Market's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 12, 2026
  • Butterfield Market Madison Ave

    Usually has it2 productsUpper East Side
    1150 Madison Ave · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Butterfield Market's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 12, 2026
  • Chatham Real Food Market Co-Op

    Usually has itChatham
    15 Church St · Chatham
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Cherry Hill Gourmet

    Usually has it2 productsSheepshead Bay
    1901 Emmons Ave · Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn
    Cherry Hill Gourmet's online shop · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Churchtown Dairy

    Usually has itHudson
    357 County Route 12 · Hudson
    Churchtown Dairy's Google Maps reviews · checked Oct 8, 2026
  • Citarella Greenwich

    Usually has itGreenwich
    600 West Putnam Ave · Greenwich
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Southampton

    Usually has itSouthampton
    22 Hampton Rd · Southampton
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Upper East Side

    Usually has itUpper East Side
    1313 3rd Ave · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Upper West Side

    Usually has it$9.99 eachUpper West Side
    2135 Broadway · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Citarella Upper West Side on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Citarella West Village

    Usually has itGreenwich Village
    424 6th Ave · Greenwich Village, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Westhampton Beach

    Usually has itWesthampton Beach
    141 Montauk Hwy · Westhampton Beach
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Cornucopia Natural Foods

    Usually has it$9.99Ronkonkoma
    3 Hawkins Ave Unit #1107 · Ronkonkoma
    Cornucopia's online shop (Ronkonkoma), in stock · checked Nov 16, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Ardsley

    Usually has itArdsley
    21 Center St · Ardsley
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Armonk

    Usually has itArmonk
    17 Maple Ave · Armonk
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Bedford

    Usually has itBedford
    422 Old Post Rd · Bedford
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Brewster

    Usually has itBrewster
    50 Independence Way · Brewster
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Greenwich

    Usually has itGreenwich
    21 Glenville St · Greenwich
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Harrison

    Usually has itHarrison
    7 Halstead Ave · Harrison
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Larchmont

    Usually has itLarchmont
    2141 Palmer Ave · Larchmont
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Millwood

    Usually has itMillwood
    230 Saw Mill River Rd · Millwood
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Pelham

    Usually has itPelham
    43 5th Ave · Pelham
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Scarsdale

    Usually has itScarsdale
    777 White Plains Rd · Scarsdale
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Somers

    Usually has itSomers
    266 Route 202 · Somers
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • DeCicco & Sons Tarrytown

    Usually has itTarrytown
    1 Legend Dr · Tarrytown
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Dumbo Market (Key Food)

    Usually has it2 productsLong Island City
    2-33 50th Avenue · Long Island City, Queens
    Dumbo Market (Key Food) on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 16, 2026
  • Eataly Downtown

    Usually has itFinancial District
    101 Liberty St, 4 World Trade Center · Financial District, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Eataly Flatiron

    Usually has itFlatiron District
    200 5th Ave · Flatiron District, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 2131 Broadway

    Usually has itUpper West Side
    2131 Broadway · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 240 E 86th St

    Usually has itUpper East Side
    240 E 86th St · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 550 2nd Ave

    Usually has itKips Bay
    550 2nd Ave · Kips Bay, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 766 6th Ave

    Usually has itFlatiron District
    766 6th Ave · Flatiron District, Manhattan
    Stocked at most Fairway branches; this branch not checked
  • Fiddleheads Food Co-op

    Usually has it$12.99New London
    13 Broad St · New London
    Fiddleheads Food Co-op's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 16, 2026
  • Food Cellar & Co 47th Rd

    Usually has itLong Island City
    4-85 47th Rd · Long Island City, Queens
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Food Cellar & Co Crescent St

    Usually has it$3.29Long Island City
    43-18 Crescent St · Long Island City, Queens
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Foodtown Brooklyn Heights

    Usually has it2 productsBrooklyn Heights
    101 Clinton St · Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
    Foodtown Brooklyn Heights on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Foodtown Fresh Meadows

    Usually has itFresh Meadows
    70-63 Parsons Blvd · Fresh Meadows, Queens
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fresh'r Farmers Market

    Usually has it$14.99Lincoln Park
    261 Comly Rd · Lincoln Park
    Fresh'r Farmers Market's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Freshtown

    Usually has itAmenia
    5094 Route 22 · Amenia
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Giunta's Meat Farms Hauppauge

    Usually has itHauppauge
    575 Nesconset Hwy · Hauppauge
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Giunta's Meat Farms Patchogue

    Usually has itPatchogue
    399 Medford Ave · Patchogue
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Glynwood Farm Store

    Usually has itCold Spring
    362 Glynwood Rd · Cold Spring
    @glynwoodfarmstore on Instagram, 2026-05-18 · checked May 18, 2026
  • Go-Pal Supermarkets

    Usually has itEdison
    1083 Inman Ave · Edison
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Grace's Marketplace

    Usually has itUpper East Side
    1299 2nd Ave · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Green Valley Gourmet Market

    Usually has it$11.04 eachBushwick
    268 Knickerbocker Ave · Bushwick, Brooklyn
    Green Valley Gourmet Market on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 20, 2026
  • Green Way Markets

    Usually has itCross River
    1 Orchard Plz · Cross River
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Green's Natural Foods Basking Ridge

    Usually has itBasking Ridge
    25 Mountainview Blvd · Basking Ridge
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Green's Natural Foods Ocean

    Usually has itOcean
    1119 Hwy 35 · Ocean
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Green's Natural Foods Shrewsbury

    Usually has itShrewsbury
    490 Broad St · Shrewsbury
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Greens Natural Foods Baldwin Place

    Usually has itBaldwin Place
    57 Us-6 · Baldwin Place
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Greens Natural Foods Mount Kisco

    Usually has itMount Kisco
    666 Lexington Ave · Mount Kisco
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Guido's Fresh Marketplace

    Usually has itGreat Barrington
    760 S Main St · Great Barrington
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Happier Grocery

    Usually has it2 productsSoHo
    365 Canal St · SoHo, Manhattan
    Happier Grocery's online shop · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Health & Harmony

    Usually has itWest Village
    470 Hudson St · West Village, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Heavenly Foodmarket

    Usually has itChelsea
    311 11th Ave · Chelsea, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Honest Weight Food Co-op

    Usually has itAlbany
    100 Watervliet Ave · Albany
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Istanbul Grand Bazaar

    Usually has itGrant City
    2189 Hylan Blvd · Grant City, Staten Island
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Jubilee Marketplace Riverside Blvd

    Usually has itUpper West Side
    180 Riverside Blvd · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Key Food 8772 18th Avenue

    Usually has it$3.75 eachBath Beach
    8772 18th Avenue · Brooklyn
    Key Food 8772 18th Avenue on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 20, 2026
  • Key Food Jersey City

    Usually has it$5.99 eachJersey City
    574 Jersey Ave · Jersey City
    Key Food Jersey City on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 16, 2026
  • La Bella Marketplace Dyker Heights

    Usually has it$2.79Dyker Heights
    7907 13th Ave · Dyker Heights, Brooklyn
    La Bella Marketplace website, listed at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • LaBonne's Epicure Market Salisbury

    Usually has it2 productsSalisbury
    22 Academy St · Salisbury
    LaBonne's online shop, listed at this store · checked Oct 29, 2026
  • Laughing Fork Farm

    Usually has itHighland
    690 New Paltz Rd · Highland
    @laughingforkfarm on Instagram, 2026-10-17 · checked Oct 17, 2026
  • LifeThyme Natural Market

    Usually has it4 productsGreenwich Village
    410 6th Ave · Greenwich Village, Manhattan
    LifeThyme's online shop · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Locust Valley Market

    Usually has itLocust Valley
    220 Birch Hill Rd · Locust Valley
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Market 360

    Usually has itNew Haven
    777 Chapel St · New Haven
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Mattituck Marketplace

    Usually has itMattituck
    10095 Main Rd · Mattituck
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Maywood's Marketplace

    Usually has itMaywood
    78 W Pleasant Ave · Maywood
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Met Fresh

    Usually has itChinatown
    7 Madison St · Chinatown, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Met Fresh Bay Ridge

    Usually has itBay Ridge
    9606 3rd Ave · Bay Ridge, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Met Fresh Bed-Stuy

    Usually has itBedford-Stuyvesant
    410 Tompkins Ave · Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Morton Williams 130 Bleecker St

    Usually has it$9.99Greenwich Village
    130 Bleecker St · Greenwich Village, Manhattan
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Mother Earth's Storehouse

    Usually has itKingston
    300 Kings Mall Court · Kingston
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Mother Earth's Storehouse Saugerties

    Usually has itSaugerties
    249 Main St · Saugerties
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Bellmore

    Usually has itBellmore
    2820 Jerusalem Ave · Bellmore
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Commack

    Usually has itCommack
    40 Vanderbilt Pkwy · Commack
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Glen Cove

    Usually has itGlen Cove
    190 Glen Cove Ave · Glen Cove
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Great Neck

    Usually has itGreat Neck
    90 Horace Harding Blvd · Great Neck
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Hauppauge

    Usually has itHauppauge
    1235 Veterans Memorial Hwy · Hauppauge
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Mamaroneck

    Usually has itMamaroneck
    805 Mamaroneck Ave · Mamaroneck
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Mineola

    Usually has itMineola
    330 E Jericho Tpke · Mineola
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Port Washington

    Usually has itPort Washington
    770 Port Washington Blvd · Port Washington
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • North Shore Farms Whitestone

    Usually has itWhitestone
    153-01 10th Ave · Whitestone, Queens
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Okka Foods Market

    Usually has itSheepshead Bay
    1524 Kings Hwy · Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Old World Food Market

    Usually has itNyack
    40 Rt 59 · Nyack
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Pioneer Supermarket Columbus Ave

    Usually has itUpper West Side
    289 Columbus Ave · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Portokali Gourmet Market

    Usually has itSheepshead Bay
    1519 Sheepshead Bay Rd · Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Qualita Mart

    Usually has it$13.99Cherry Hill
    2060 Springdale Rd · Cherry Hill
    Qualita Mart's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • And 169 more stores.

Brands spotted10

  • Bellwether FarmsIn stock at LifeThyme Natural Market, Whole Foods Fort Greene, Whole Foods Gowanus and 18 more; listed for 63 stores
  • Old Chatham CreameryIn stock at A Matter of Health, Happier Grocery, Wegmans Astor Place and 13 more; listed for 21 stores
  • Old Chatham SheepherdingIn stock at Whole Foods Fort Greene, Whole Foods Gowanus, Whole Foods Williamsburg and 12 more
  • Old ChathamIn stock at LifeThyme Natural Market, Basil Bandwagon Natural Market; listed for 2 stores
  • Valley Shepherd CreameryIn stock at Whole Foods Ridgewood, Whole Foods One Wall Street; listed for 1 store
  • UrfarmIn stock at Fresh'r Farmers Market, Qualita Mart
  • Natures PerfectIn stock at Westside Market 2840 Broadway; listed for 1 store
  • BellwetherIn stock at Happier Grocery
  • Old Chatman CreameryIn stock at Cherry Hill Gourmet
  • Simply SheepIn stock at La Bella Marketplace Dyker Heights
Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there