
Meat, eggs & dairy
Stores that usually have Sheep’s milk yogurt: A Matter of Health (Nanuet, NY), Amagansett IGA (Amagansett, NY), Austin Organic Market (Forest Hills, Queens) and 153 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 28 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
Also sold as sheep milk yogurt, sheep yogurt, sheep yoghurt, sheep’s yogurt, ewe’s milk yogurt, Old Chatham yogurt.
Substitute Greek yogurt or plain whole-milk yogurt.