The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Stores

Manhattan

Specialty grocers in Upper West Side

44 stores in Upper West Side are on our list. Best stocked: Brooklyn Fare West End Ave, Fairway 2131 Broadway and Pioneer Supermarket Columbus Ave.

Good for: New York & Jewish deli · French · British & Irish

Stores in Upper West Side44

  • Brooklyn Fare West End Ave

    Gourmet market · 75 West End Avenue

    Usually has 556 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Lingonberry jam, Pickled garlic, Double cream and Cabrales

  • Fairway 2131 Broadway

    Supermarket · 2131 Broadway

    Usually has 513 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Sundowner apples, Korean chili threads, Alligator meat and Kangaroo meat

  • Pioneer Supermarket Columbus Ave

    Supermarket · 289 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 431 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Txistorra, Nürnberger sausages, English peas (in the pod) and Unagi sauce

  • Jubilee Marketplace Riverside Blvd

    Supermarket · 180 Riverside Blvd

    Usually has 410 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Txistorra, Cadbury Flake, Carob and Sale di Trapani

  • Zabar's

    Gourmet market · 2245 Broadway

    Usually has 396 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Halen Môn, Pérail, Soumaintrain and Roncal

  • Citarella Upper West Side

    Gourmet market · 2135 Broadway

    Usually has 378 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Langoustines, Corbarino tomatoes, Coulommiers and Cheddar (Isle of Mull)

  • Whole Foods Columbus Circle

    Supermarket · 10 Columbus Circle

    Usually has 350 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cashel Blue, Kimchi paste, Hakka egg noodles and Wagon Wheels

  • Whole Foods Upper West Side

    Supermarket · 808 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 334 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cheshire, Piccalilli, Cashel Blue and Kimchi paste

  • Morton Williams 2015 Broadway

    Supermarket · 2015 Broadway

    Usually has 290 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Salad cream, Saint Albray, Cultured French butter and Schmaltz

  • Westside Market 2589 Broadway

    Supermarket · 2589 Broadway

    Usually has 276 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Shropshire Blue, Secret Aardvark, Rhubarb and Reggianito

  • Key Food 733 Amsterdam Avenue

    Supermarket · 733 Amsterdam Avenue

    Usually has 254 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Linden honey, Cardoons, Doenjang and Ssamjang

  • Key Food 2401 Broadway

    Supermarket · 2401 Broadway

    Usually has 247 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Doenjang, EverCrisp apples, Ssamjang and Oha leaves

  • Gourmet Garage W 66th St

    Supermarket · 155 W 66th St

    Usually has 225 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Traditional balsamic vinegar, Rhubarb, Saint Albray and WildTwist apples

  • Morton Williams 917 9th Ave

    Supermarket · 917 9th Ave

    Usually has 224 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cultured French butter, Ají dulce, Veal osso buco and Aura apples

  • Morton Williams 15 West End Ave

    Supermarket · 15 West End Ave

    Usually has 223 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cultured French butter, Ají dulce, Veal osso buco and Aura apples

  • Key Food 530 Amsterdam Ave

    Supermarket · 530 Amsterdam Ave

    Usually has 222 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including EverCrisp apples, Achiote oil, Uni and Culantro (fresh)

  • Zingone Brothers

    Grocery · 471 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 180 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Black cardamom (whole), Pimentón de la Vera, MCT oil and Green peppercorns

  • Gristedes 504 Columbus Ave

    Supermarket · 504 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 176 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Biltong, Spaghetti alla chitarra, Redcurrant jelly and Paccheri

  • Freshy's

    Grocery · 941 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 174 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Maltesers, Crunchie, Murabba and Frozen momos

  • Gristedes 2704 Broadway

    Supermarket · 2704 Broadway

    Usually has 163 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Biltong, Spaghetti alla chitarra, Cape gooseberries and Tagliatelle

  • Columbus FoodMarket (Key Food)

    Supermarket · 81 West 104th St

    Usually has 136 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Kohlrabi, Potato flour, Tinned mussels and Vital wheat gluten

  • D'Agostino 633 Columbus Ave

    Supermarket · 633 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 134 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Sweet Sapphire grapes, Green mango, Spaghetti alla chitarra and Elote seasoning

  • Trader Joe's 2073 Broadway

    Supermarket · 2073 Broadway

    Usually has 118 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Knife-cut noodles, Pepper soup spice, Nordic salmon spice and Brunost

  • Trader Joe's 670 Columbus Ave

    Supermarket · 670 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 118 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Knife-cut noodles, Pepper soup spice, Nordic salmon spice and Brunost

  • The Kosher Marketplace

    Kosher supermarket · 2442 Broadway

    Usually has 92 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Sweetbreads, Dried limes, Veal breast and Pimentón de la Vera

  • H Mart Amsterdam Ave

    Korean supermarket · 210 Amsterdam Ave

    Usually has 87 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Japanese sesame dressing, Satay sauce, Shrimp crackers and Enoki mushrooms

  • Central Market

    Supermarket · 220 Manhattan Ave

    Usually has 76 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cara Cara oranges, SnapDragon apples, Cotton Candy grapes and Blood oranges

  • Associated Supermarket W 100th St

    Supermarket · 13-15 W 100th St

    Usually has 75 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Turkey wings, Cara Cara oranges, Beef knuckle and Cotton Candy grapes

  • Target Upper West Side 61st and Broadway

    Department store · 1863 Broadway

    Usually has 54 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Hello Panda, Standing rib roast (prime rib), Coconut aminos and Chili garlic sauce

  • Jaleby

    South Asian grocery · 941 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 38 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Maltesers, Dosa mix, Papadums and Asafoetida

  • Target Upper West Side 98th and Columbus

    Department store · 795 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 33 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Standing rib roast (prime rib), Hi-Chew, Cosmic Crisp apples and Everything bagel seasoning

  • Hashi Market Upper West Side

    Japanese grocery · 2780 Broadway

    Usually has 25 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Yakisoba noodles, Ramen noodles, Century eggs and Cooking sake

  • Murray's Sturgeon Shop

    Appetizing shop · 2429 Broadway

    Usually has 19 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Zamorano, Sable, Smoked sturgeon and Clothbound cheddar

  • Barney Greengrass

    Appetizing shop · 541 Amsterdam Ave

    Usually has 16 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Sable, Smoked sturgeon, Blini and Nigella seeds

  • The Health Nuts

    Natural foods market · 2611 Broadway

    Usually has 5 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Tempeh, Kefir, Tahini and Pomegranates

  • Mani Market Place

    Greek grocery · 697 Columbus Ave

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

  • 79th Street Greenmarket

    Farmers market · 79th St. & Columbus Ave.

  • 97th Street Greenmarket

    Farmers market · 97th St. bet. Columbus & Amsterdam Aves

  • Beer Run Upper West Side

    Beer shop and bar · 547 Columbus Ave

  • Carnegie Market

    Grocery · 148 W 67th St

  • Five Below 805 Columbus Ave

    Discount store · 805 Columbus Ave

  • Hudson & Charles Upper West Side

    Butcher · 555 Amsterdam Ave

  • Mast Market

    Gourmet market · 353 Columbus Ave

  • Tucker Square Greenmarket

    Farmers market · 66th St. & Broadway

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there