The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Cuisines

European

British & Irish ingredients

Cheeses, sausages and sweets: Cornish Yarg, Lancashire, Cumberland sausage and Pontefract cakes (licorice discs). Gentleman's relish and Shreddies too, for the homesick.

Best stocked for British & Irish ingredients: Myers of Keswick (West Village, Manhattan), The Hamlet (Mount Kisco, NY) and Shi Eurasia (Big Cheers) (Lower East Side, Manhattan).

By country: English

British & Irish pantry essentials10

Best stores for British & Irish ingredients5

  1. 1

    Myers of Keswick

    West Village, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 46 of the 100 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Haggis, Shreddies, Yorkshire puddings and Black treacle

  2. 2

    The Hamlet

    Mount Kisco, NY · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 43 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Shreddies, Yorkshire puddings, Pontefract cakes and Black treacle

  3. 3

    Shi Eurasia (Big Cheers)

    Lower East Side, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 37 of the 100 · sometimes 10 more

    Including Shreddies, Yorkshire puddings, Black treacle and Pot Noodle

  4. 4

    Tea & Sympathy

    West Village, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 25 of the 100 · sometimes 11 more

    Including Black treacle, Pot Noodle, Double cream and Maltesers

  5. 5

    Sweet O'clock

    East Village, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 24 of the 100

    Including Pontefract cakes, Pot Noodle, White pudding and Maltesers

By area: New Jersey · Manhattan · Brooklyn · Long Island · Connecticut · Queens · the Hudson Valley · Westchester · the Bronx · Staten Island · upstate New York

Best in New Jersey5

  1. 1

    Wegmans Ocean

    Ocean, NJ · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 29 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Christmas pudding, Salad cream, Suet and HP Sauce

  2. 2

    Kings Food Markets Montclair

    Montclair, NJ · Supermarket · and 9 other branches

    Usually has 25 of the 100

    Including Poussin, Christmas pudding, Muscovado sugar and HP Sauce

  3. 3

    Wegmans Parsippany

    Parsippany, NJ · Supermarket

    Usually has 27 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Christmas pudding, Salad cream, Suet and HP Sauce

  4. 4

    Wegmans Manalapan

    Manalapan, NJ · Supermarket

    Usually has 27 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Christmas pudding, Salad cream, Suet and HP Sauce

  5. 5

    Go-Pal Supermarkets

    Edison, NJ · Supermarket

    Usually has 26 of the 100

    Including Golden syrup, Sea moss, Mint sauce and Leicester (red)

Best in Manhattan5

  1. 1

    Myers of Keswick

    West Village, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 46 of the 100 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Haggis, Shreddies, Yorkshire puddings and Black treacle

  2. 2

    Shi Eurasia (Big Cheers)

    Lower East Side, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 37 of the 100 · sometimes 10 more

    Including Shreddies, Yorkshire puddings, Black treacle and Pot Noodle

  3. 3

    Tea & Sympathy

    West Village, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 25 of the 100 · sometimes 11 more

    Including Black treacle, Pot Noodle, Double cream and Maltesers

  4. 4

    Sweet O'clock

    East Village, Manhattan · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 24 of the 100

    Including Pontefract cakes, Pot Noodle, White pudding and Maltesers

  5. 5

    Zabar's

    Upper West Side, Manhattan · Gourmet market

    Usually has 29 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Stichelton, Caerphilly, Gooseberry jam and Cheshire

Best in Brooklyn5

  1. 1

    Fferins of Brooklyn

    Park Slope, Brooklyn · Specialty food shop

    Usually has 10 of the 100

    Including Pontefract cakes, Crunchie, Wine gums and Cadbury Flake

  2. 2

    Jubilee Marketplace West St

    Greenpoint, Brooklyn · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 100 · sometimes 8 more

    Including Cheshire, Brandy butter, Anchovy essence and Muscovado sugar

  3. 3

    SuperFresh Bay Ridge

    Bay Ridge, Brooklyn · Supermarket · and 5 other branches

    Usually has 22 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Gooseberry jam, Wine gums, Cadbury Flake and Mint sauce

  4. 4

    Two for the Pot

    Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn · Tea shop

    Usually has 6 of the 100

    Including Crunchie, Cadbury Flake, Jaffa Cakes and Licorice allsorts

  5. 5

    Lincoln Market Prospect Lefferts Gardens

    Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Brooklyn · Grocery · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Double cream, Cheshire, Cashel Blue and Clotted cream

Best on Long Island5

  1. 1

    Village Market

    Floral Park, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 100

    Including Weetabix & Weet-Bix, White pudding, Black pudding and Crunchie

  2. 2

    Uncle Giuseppe's Bohemia

    Bohemia, NY · Italian grocery · and 8 other branches

    Usually has 25 of the 100 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Brandy butter, Derby (sage), Damson jam and Goose

  3. 3

    Wegmans Lake Grove

    Lake Grove, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 100

    Including Christmas pudding, Salad cream, HP Sauce and Golden syrup

  4. 4

    Locust Valley Market

    Locust Valley, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 22 of the 100

    Including Christmas pudding, Clotted cream, Dried currants and Marmalade

  5. 5

    Community Food Market

    Huntington Station, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 23 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Gentleman's relish, Mixed spice, Cheshire and Anchovy essence

Best in Connecticut5

  1. 1

    Palmer's Market

    Darien, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 38 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Gooseberry jam, Cashel Blue, Piccalilli and Damson jam

  2. 2

    Bishop's Orchards

    Guilford, CT · Farm stand

    Usually has 22 of the 100 · sometimes 7 more

    Including Cheshire, Cashel Blue, Derby (sage) and Poussin

  3. 3

    Walter Stewart's Market

    New Canaan, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 22 of the 100 · sometimes 9 more

    Including Pheasant, Damson jam, Blackcurrant jam and HP Sauce

  4. 4

    Highland Park Market Glastonbury

    Glastonbury, CT · Gourmet market · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 100

    Including Suet, HP Sauce, Golden syrup and Mint sauce

  5. 5

    Caraluzzis Newtown Market

    Newtown, CT · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 15 of the 100 · sometimes 10 more

    Including Blackcurrant jam, Muscovado sugar, HP Sauce and Golden syrup

Best in Queens5

  1. 1

    Butcher Block

    Sunnyside, Queens · British and Irish butcher

    Usually has 9 of the 100

    Including White pudding, Black pudding, Crunchie and Cadbury Flake

  2. 2

    Foodtown Fresh Meadows

    Fresh Meadows, Queens · Supermarket · and 7 other branches

    Usually has 28 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Goose, Golden syrup, Sea moss and Mint sauce

  3. 3

    Food Cellar & Co 47th Rd

    Long Island City, Queens · Supermarket

    Usually has 22 of the 100

    Including Christmas pudding, Muscovado sugar, HP Sauce and Clotted cream

  4. 4

    Stop & Shop 74-17 Grand Ave

    Maspeth, Queens · Supermarket · and 10 other branches

    Usually has 17 of the 100 · sometimes 11 more

    Including Branston Pickle, Licorice allsorts, Yeast extract spread and Custard powder

  5. 5

    Dumbo Market (Key Food)

    Long Island City, Queens · Supermarket · and 54 other branches

    Usually has 18 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Muscovado sugar, Clotted cream, Licorice allsorts and Yeast extract spread

Best in the Hudson Valley5

  1. 1

    Old World Food Market

    Nyack, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 23 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Cashel Blue, Derby (sage), Shropshire Blue and Sea moss

  2. 2

    DeCicco & Sons Brewster

    Brewster, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 22 of the 100 · sometimes 6 more

    Including Shropshire Blue, Cotswold, Cockles and Sea moss

  3. 3

    Stop & Shop Hyde Park

    Hyde Park, NY · Supermarket · and 10 other branches

    Usually has 16 of the 100 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Branston Pickle, Yeast extract spread, Custard powder and Mincemeat

  4. 4

    Mother Earth's Storehouse

    Kingston, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 15 of the 100

    Including Blackcurrant jam, Sea moss, Clotted cream and Marmalade

  5. 5

    Market Fresh

    Newburgh, NY · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 17 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Glacé cherries, Sea moss, Dried currants and Marmalade

Best in Westchester5

  1. 1

    The Hamlet

    Mount Kisco, NY · British and Irish grocery

    Usually has 43 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Shreddies, Yorkshire puddings, Pontefract cakes and Black treacle

  2. 2

    Ideal Fresh Market

    Yonkers, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 24 of the 100

    Including Weetabix & Weet-Bix, Gooseberry jam, White pudding and Black pudding

  3. 3

    Wegmans West Harrison

    West Harrison, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 29 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Christmas pudding, Salad cream, HP Sauce and Golden syrup

  4. 4

    DeCicco & Sons Scarsdale

    Scarsdale, NY · Supermarket · and 10 other branches

    Usually has 27 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Shropshire Blue, Poussin, Muscovado sugar and Cotswold

  5. 5

    Stop & Shop Yonkers

    Yonkers, NY · Supermarket · and 12 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 100

    Including Golden syrup, Mint sauce, Branston Pickle and Licorice allsorts

Best in the Bronx5

  1. 1

    CTown 4265 Katonah Ave

    Woodlawn, Bronx · Supermarket · and 25 other branches

    Usually has 27 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Black treacle, Pot Noodle, White pudding and Maltesers

  2. 2

    Stop & Shop 5716 Broadway

    Kingsbridge, Bronx · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 14 of the 100 · sometimes 7 more

    Including Mint sauce, Branston Pickle, Yeast extract spread and Custard powder

  3. 3

    Pruzzo's Supermarket

    Pelham Bay, Bronx · Supermarket

    Usually has 11 of the 100

    Including White pudding, Black pudding, HP Sauce and Marmalade

  4. 4

    Stop & Shop 1720 Eastchester Rd

    Morris Park, Bronx · Supermarket

    Usually has 10 of the 100 · sometimes 7 more

    Including Crystallized ginger, Wensleydale, Tallow and Mint jelly

  5. 5

    Food Bazaar E 163rd St

    Melrose, Bronx · Supermarket · and 10 other branches

    Usually has 13 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Cockles, Leicester (red), Marmalade and Gloucester

Best in Staten Island5

  1. 1

    Stop & Shop 1441 Yona Ave

    Bull's Head, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 14 of the 100 · sometimes 7 more

    Including Branston Pickle, Licorice allsorts, Yeast extract spread and Crystallized ginger

  2. 2

    ShopRite 2656 Hylan Blvd

    Richmond Town, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 14 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Glacé cherries, Golden syrup, Dover sole and Hot English mustard

  3. 3

    La Bella Marketplace Tottenville

    Tottenville, Staten Island · Supermarket

    Usually has 14 of the 100

    Including Glacé cherries, Derby (sage), Marmalade and Licorice allsorts

  4. 4

    CTown 2071 Clove Rd

    Concord, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 12 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Cumberland sausage, Marmalade, Custard powder and Redcurrant jelly

  5. 5

    Widdi's Food Market

    Rossville, Staten Island · Supermarket

    Usually has 12 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Cockles, Sea moss, Yeast extract spread and Digestive biscuits

Best in upstate New York5

  1. 1

    Honest Weight Food Co-op

    Albany, NY · Natural foods market

    Usually has 18 of the 100 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Derby (sage), Shropshire Blue, Blackcurrant jam and Suet

  2. 2

    Hannaford Voorheesville

    Voorheesville, NY · Supermarket · and 9 other branches

    Usually has 11 of the 100 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Dried currants, Redcurrant jelly, Stilton and Lemon curd

  3. 3

    Trader Joe's Albany

    Albany, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 7 of the 100

    Including Cotswold, Leicester (red), Gloucester and Stilton

  4. 4

    ALDI Latham

    Latham, NY · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 6 of the 100

    Including Jaffa Cakes, Gloucester, Stilton and Tallow

  5. 5

    Whole Foods Albany

    Albany, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 7 of the 100 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Hot English mustard, Wensleydale, Lemon curd and Tallow

British & Irish ingredients we track100

Herbs & fresh produce

Pastes, sauces & condiments

Spices & seasonings

Dried goods

Pickles & ferments

Fish & seafood

Pantry

Flours & baking

Snacks, sweets & convenience

Meat, eggs & dairy

Cheese

Drinks & bar

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there