
Cheese
Stores that usually have Cheddar (Isle of Mull): Citarella Upper East Side (Manhattan), Citarella West Village (Greenwich Village, Manhattan), Dobbs & Bishop Fine Cheese (Bronxville, NY) and 9 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
A firm English-born cow's milk cheese made by cheddaring the curd; from mild and creamy to sharp and crystalline with age.
isleofmullAlso sold as cheddar cheese, isle of mull, mull cheddar.
In British & Irish cooking.
Substitute colby Jack or Gouda.