The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Back to the index
Cheddar (Isle of Mull)

Cheese

Cheddar (Isle of Mull)

Stores that usually have Cheddar (Isle of Mull): Citarella Upper East Side (Manhattan), Citarella West Village (Greenwich Village, Manhattan), Dobbs & Bishop Fine Cheese (Bronxville, NY) and 9 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.

A firm English-born cow's milk cheese made by cheddaring the curd; from mild and creamy to sharp and crystalline with age.

isleofmullAlso sold as cheddar cheese, isle of mull, mull cheddar.

In British & Irish cooking.

Substitute colby Jack or Gouda.

Where to find it16 stores

  • Citarella Greenwich

    Usually has itGreenwich
    600 West Putnam Ave · Greenwich
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Southampton

    Usually has itSouthampton
    22 Hampton Rd · Southampton
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Upper East Side

    Usually has itUpper East Side
    1313 3rd Ave · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Upper West Side

    Usually has it$43.99 per lbUpper West Side
    2135 Broadway · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Citarella Upper West Side on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Citarella West Village

    Usually has itGreenwich Village
    424 6th Ave · Greenwich Village, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella Westhampton Beach

    Usually has itWesthampton Beach
    141 Montauk Hwy · Westhampton Beach
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Dobbs & Bishop Fine Cheese

    Usually has itBronxville
    107 Pondfield Rd · Bronxville
    Dobbs & Bishop's cheese menu board (photo from Jack) · checked Oct 30, 2026
  • Fromage Fine Foods & Coffees

    Usually has itOld Saybrook
    873 Boston Post Rd · Old Saybrook
    Fromage Fine Foods & Coffees's website · checked Jan 1, 2025
  • Guido's Fresh Marketplace

    Usually has itGreat Barrington
    760 S Main St · Great Barrington
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Murray's Cheese Bleecker St

    Usually has it$24.00West Village
    254 Bleecker St · West Village, Manhattan
    Murray's Cheese online shop, listed · checked Nov 1, 2026
  • Van Hook Cheese & Grocery

    Usually has itMontclair
    111 Grove St · Montclair
    Van Hook Cheese on Instagram · checked Oct 9, 2026
  • Van Hook Cheese + Grocery

    Usually has itJersey City
    528 Jersey Ave · Jersey City
    Van Hook Cheese on Instagram · checked Oct 9, 2026
  • Citarella Bridgehampton

    Might have itBridgehampton
    2209 Montauk Hwy · Bridgehampton
    In Citarella's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Citarella East Hampton

    Might have itEast Hampton
    2 Pantigo Rd · East Hampton
    In Citarella's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Darien Cheese & Fine Foods

    Might have itDarien
    25 Old Kings Hwy North · Darien
    Darien Cheese & Fine Foods on Instagram (Nov 2020) · checked Nov 18, 2020
  • Murray's Cheese Grand Central

    Might have it$24.00Midtown
    Grand Central Market, 89 E 42nd St · Midtown, Manhattan
    Murray's Cheese online shop, listed (the chain's online shop; this branch not checked) · checked Nov 1, 2026
Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there