The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Stores

Manhattan

Specialty grocers in Upper East Side

49 stores in Upper East Side are on our list. Best stocked: Fairway 240 E 86th St, Grace's Marketplace and CTown 1721 1st Ave.

Good for: Italian · French · German

Stores in Upper East Side49

  • Fairway 240 E 86th St

    Supermarket · 240 E 86th St

    Usually has 581 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Yorkshire puddings, Sundowner apples, Korean chili threads and Alligator meat

  • Grace's Marketplace

    Gourmet market · 1299 2nd Ave

    Usually has 380 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Takanotsume chilies, Bouquet garni, White anchovies and Blutwurst

  • CTown 1721 1st Ave

    Supermarket · 1721 First Avenue

    Usually has 368 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Whole fig jam, Huazontle, Romano beans (flat beans) and Green Dragon apples

  • Dumbo Market (Key Food)

    Supermarket · 1223 2nd Avenue

    Usually has 368 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Armenian cucumbers, Zab's, Togarashi and Coffee extract

  • Morton Williams 1565 1st Ave

    Supermarket · 1565 1st Ave

    Usually has 352 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Rosé wine vinegar, Seckel pears, Goose and Blackcurrant jam

  • A Matter of Health

    Natural foods market · 1347 1st Ave

    Usually has 338 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bergamot extract, Marula oil, Low-FODMAP stock and Bee balm

  • Citarella Upper East Side

    Gourmet market · 1313 3rd Ave

    Usually has 338 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Corbarino tomatoes, Coulommiers, Cheddar (Isle of Mull) and Tasmanian pepperberry

  • Whole Foods Upper East Side

    Supermarket · 1551 3rd Ave

    Usually has 325 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Caerphilly, Cheshire, Kimchi paste and Secret Aardvark

  • Key Food 1769 2nd Avenue

    Supermarket · 1769 2nd Avenue

    Usually has 305 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cardoons, Ssamjang, Oha leaves and Camel milk

  • Morton Williams 1066 3rd Ave

    Supermarket · 1066 3rd Ave

    Usually has 282 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bûcheron, Salad cream, Saint Albray and Cultured French butter

  • Morton Williams 1211 Madison Ave

    Supermarket · 1211 Madison Ave

    Usually has 272 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bûcheron, Saint Albray, Cultured French butter and Schmaltz

  • Morton Williams 1251 3rd Ave

    Supermarket · 1251 3rd Ave

    Usually has 254 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bûcheron, Saint Albray, Cultured French butter and Long red chilies

  • Westside Market 1407 Lexington Ave

    Supermarket · 1407 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 253 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Rhubarb, Reggianito, Chaumes and Muscovado sugar

  • D'Agostino 1507 York Ave

    Supermarket · 1507 York Ave

    Usually has 245 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Rosé wine vinegar, Sweet Sapphire grapes, Saint Albray and Artichoke paste

  • Whole Foods Lenox Hill

    Supermarket · 1175 3rd Ave

    Usually has 242 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Busiate, MCT oil, Rillettes and Tom yum paste

  • Gristedes

    Supermarket · 1644 York Ave

    Usually has 238 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Pinova apples, 20th Century pears, Seckel pears and Mutsu apples

  • Food Universe Lexington Ave

    Supermarket · 1486 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 225 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Clear rice wine, Ssamjang, Slap Ya Mama and Glass noodles

  • Morton Williams 1331 1st Ave

    Supermarket · 1331 1st Ave

    Usually has 221 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cultured French butter, Ají dulce, Veal osso buco and Aura apples

  • Gristedes 1446 2nd Ave

    Supermarket · 1446 2nd Ave

    Usually has 202 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Strozzapreti, Christstollen, Biltong and Spaghetti alla chitarra

  • D'Agostino 1074 Lexington Ave

    Supermarket · 1074 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 159 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Sweet Sapphire grapes, Green mango, Scotch bonnets and Biltong

  • Gristedes 1343 Lexington Ave

    Supermarket · 1343 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 146 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Strozzapreti, Biltong, Redcurrant jelly and New Mexico chiles

  • D'Agostino 1233 Lexington Ave

    Supermarket · 1233 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 143 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Sweet Sapphire grapes, Artichoke paste, Green mango and Spaghetti alla chitarra

  • Gristedes 1208 1st Ave

    Supermarket · 1208 1st Ave

    Usually has 136 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Spaghetti alla chitarra, New Mexico chiles, Yellowbird and Risotto rice

  • Park East Kosher

    Kosher grocery · 1733 1st Ave

    Usually has 122 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Veal cheeks, Sweetbreads, Goose and Freekeh

  • Trader Joe's 405 E 59th Street

    Supermarket · 405 E 59th Street

    Usually has 118 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Knife-cut noodles, Pepper soup spice, Nordic salmon spice and Brunost

  • East Side Grocery

    Grocery · 1422 2nd Ave

    Usually has 116 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Crunchie, Cocoa nibs, Turkish delight and Dried mulberries

  • Butterfield Market Madison Ave

    Gourmet market · 1150 Madison Ave

    Usually has 108 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Low-FODMAP stock, Salty licorice, Rosé wine vinegar and Unagi sauce

  • Gristedes 1365 3rd Ave

    Supermarket · 1365 3rd Ave

    Usually has 103 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cara Cara oranges, Risotto rice, Cactus pear and Manuka honey

  • Agata & Valentina

    Gourmet market · 1513 1st Ave

    Usually has 71 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Puntarelle, Romesco, Capon and Brie

  • Target Upper East Side 86th and Lex

    Department store · 150 E 86th St

    Usually has 69 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Hello Panda, Sanding sugar, Standing rib roast (prime rib) and Coconut aminos

  • Butterfield Market Lexington Ave

    Gourmet market · 1114 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 62 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Rosé wine vinegar, Shine Muscat grapes, Unagi sauce and Lucy Rose apples

  • Eli's Market

    Gourmet market · 1411 3rd Ave

    Usually has 58 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Seckel pears, English peas (in the pod), Poussin and Époisses

  • City Swiggers

    Beer shop and bar · 320 E 86th St

    Usually has 45 hard-to-find ingredients

  • Ouri's Market

    Kosher grocery · 1160 3rd Ave

    Usually has 44 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Khmeli suneli, Wax beans, Basturma and Grouper

  • Target Upper East Side 70th and 3rd

    Department store · 1201 3rd Ave

    Usually has 39 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Hello Panda, Standing rib roast (prime rib), Coconut aminos and Cosmic Crisp apples

  • Schaller & Weber

    German butcher · 1654 2nd Ave

    Usually has 25 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Pinkelwurst, Curry ketchup, Blutwurst and Bauernwurst

  • Lobel's Prime Meats

    Butcher · 1096 Madison Ave

    Usually has 22 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Traditional balsamic vinegar, Veal bones, Tomahawk steak and Savory

  • Brazilian Market Nyc

    Brazilian grocery · 304 East 77th St

    Usually has 20 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cupuaçu, Manioc flour, Sour tapioca starch and Mombin

  • Yamadaya Upper East Side

    Japanese grocery · 1281 3rd Ave

    Usually has 20 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Aonori, Tenkasu, Mentaiko and Shiro dashi

  • Marky's Caviar Madison Ave

    Caviar shop · 1067 Madison Ave

    Usually has 15 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bottarga, Trout roe, Flying fish roe and Foie gras

  • Milano Market

    Italian grocery · 1582 3rd Ave

    Usually has 13 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bresaola, Ricotta, Serrano ham and Speck

  • Carnegie Market

    Grocery · 1245 Park Ave

    Usually has 9 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Buckwheat, Polenta, Potato starch and Farro

  • City Hops

    Beer shop and bar · 1145 2nd Ave

    Usually has 5 hard-to-find ingredients

  • The Health Nuts

    Natural foods market · 1208 2nd Ave

    Usually has 5 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Tempeh, Kefir, Tahini and Pomegranates

  • William Poll

    Gourmet market · 1051 Lexington Ave

    Usually has 4 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Caviar, Lox, Alternative caviar and Chestnuts

  • Ruppert Park Greenmarket

    Farmers market · 90th Street & 2nd Avenue

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

    Including Lion's mane mushrooms

  • 82nd Street Greenmarket

    Farmers market · 82nd St. bet. 1st & York Aves

  • Food For Health

    Natural foods market · 1653 3rd Ave

  • Food Liberation Natural Food

    Natural foods market · 1349 Lexington Ave

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there