The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Cuisines

European

Italian ingredients

The basics are everywhere. Regional cheeses like Monte Veronese, gianduja paste, black truffles and shapes like pici are where a specialty shop earns its keep.

Best stocked for Italian ingredients: Eataly Flatiron (Flatiron District, Manhattan), Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana (Ridgefield, NJ) and Tavola Italian Market (Cobble Hill, Brooklyn).

Italian pantry essentials10

Best stores for Italian ingredients5

  1. 1

    Eataly Flatiron

    Flatiron District, Manhattan · Italian grocery · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 129 of the 201 · sometimes 18 more

    Including Taggiasca olive paste, Tajarin, Corzetti and Trenette

  2. 2

    Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana

    Ridgefield, NJ · Italian salumeria

    Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 26 more

    Including Galbanino, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Sedani and Pantelleria capers

  3. 3

    Tavola Italian Market

    Cobble Hill, Brooklyn · Italian grocery

    Usually has 72 of the 201 · sometimes 17 more

    Including Culatello, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Lardo and Fennel pollen

  4. 4

    Buon'Italia

    Chelsea, Manhattan · Italian grocery

    Usually has 79 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Balsamic jelly, Colatura di alici, Castelrosso and Castelmagno

  5. 5

    Iavarone Bros Maspeth

    Maspeth, Queens · Italian grocery · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 104 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Agnolotti, Cannelloni, Montasio and Cotechino

By area: New Jersey · Brooklyn · Long Island · Manhattan · Connecticut · Queens · the Hudson Valley · Westchester · the Bronx · Staten Island · upstate New York

Best in New Jersey5

  1. 1

    Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana

    Ridgefield, NJ · Italian salumeria

    Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 26 more

    Including Galbanino, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Sedani and Pantelleria capers

  2. 2

    Uncle Giuseppe's Ramsey

    Ramsey, NJ · Italian grocery · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 123 of the 201 · sometimes 10 more

    Including Strangozzi, Gianduja paste, Caciotta and Pici

  3. 3

    Livoti's Aberdeen

    Aberdeen, NJ · Italian grocery · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 88 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Agnolotti, Scialatielli, Ubriaco and Garganelli

  4. 4

    Eataly Short Hills

    Millburn, NJ · Italian grocery

    Usually has 62 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more

    Including Ligurian walnut sauce, Castelfranco radicchio, Bottarga and Citron (fresh)

  5. 5

    City Supermarket

    Fairview, NJ · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 92 of the 201

    Including Cannelloni, Stracchino, Garganelli and Salt-packed capers

Best in Brooklyn5

  1. 1

    Tavola Italian Market

    Cobble Hill, Brooklyn · Italian grocery

    Usually has 72 of the 201 · sometimes 17 more

    Including Culatello, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Lardo and Fennel pollen

  2. 2

    La Bella Marketplace Dyker Heights

    Dyker Heights, Brooklyn · Supermarket

    Usually has 103 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Raschera, Cannelloni, Datterini tomatoes and Squid ink

  3. 3

    Paisanos Meat Market

    Boerum Hill, Brooklyn · Italian butcher

    Usually has 79 of the 201

    Including White anchovies, Pantelleria capers, Scialatielli and Montasio

  4. 4

    Jubilee Marketplace West St

    Greenpoint, Brooklyn · Supermarket

    Usually has 91 of the 201 · sometimes 11 more

    Including Jimmy Nardello peppers, Salt-packed capers, Saba and Wild boar

  5. 5

    Whole Foods Williamsburg

    Williamsburg, Brooklyn · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 76 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Trofie, Busiate, 'Nduja and Robiola

Best on Long Island5

  1. 1

    Uncle Giuseppe's Greenvale

    Greenvale, NY · Italian grocery · and 8 other branches

    Usually has 122 of the 201 · sometimes 19 more

    Including Gianduja paste, Caciotta, Pici and Scialatielli

  2. 2

    Iavarone Brothers

    New Hyde Park, NY · Italian grocery · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 102 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Pantelleria capers, Cannelloni, Montasio and Cotechino

  3. 3

    Iavarone Bros Woodbury

    Woodbury, NY · Italian grocery

    Usually has 96 of the 201 · sometimes 6 more

    Including Cannelloni, Montasio, Cotechino and Veal breast

  4. 4

    Salpino Italian Food Market

    North Bellmore, NY · Italian grocery

    Usually has 64 of the 201

    Including Bavette, Salt-packed capers, Stelline and Caciocavallo

  5. 5

    Eastern Meat Farms

    Franklin Square, NY · Italian grocery

    Usually has 52 of the 201

    Including Bel Paese, Trofie, Caciocavallo and Tagliolini

Best in Manhattan5

  1. 1

    Eataly Flatiron

    Flatiron District, Manhattan · Italian grocery · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 129 of the 201 · sometimes 18 more

    Including Taggiasca olive paste, Tajarin, Corzetti and Trenette

  2. 2

    Buon'Italia

    Chelsea, Manhattan · Italian grocery

    Usually has 79 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Balsamic jelly, Colatura di alici, Castelrosso and Castelmagno

  3. 3

    Grace's Marketplace

    Upper East Side, Manhattan · Gourmet market

    Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including White anchovies, Bottarga, Fregola and Garganelli

  4. 4

    Via Della Scrofa

    East Village, Manhattan · Italian grocery

    Usually has 38 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Piennolo del Vesuvio, Datterini tomatoes, Salt-packed capers and Saba

  5. 5

    Raffetto's

    Greenwich Village, Manhattan · Italian pasta shop

    Usually has 38 of the 201

    Including Sedani, Cannelloni, Bel Paese and Lumache

Best in Connecticut5

  1. 1

    Palmer's Market

    Darien, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 84 of the 201 · sometimes 4 more

    Including Bergamot, White truffles, Datterini tomatoes and Squid ink

  2. 2

    DeCicco & Sons Greenwich

    Greenwich, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 94 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Raschera, Trofie, Caciocavallo and San Marzano DOP tomatoes

  3. 3

    Caraluzzi's Danbury Market

    Danbury, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 55 of the 201 · sometimes 29 more

    Including Malloreddus, Stelline, White balsamic vinegar and Fontina Val d'Aosta

  4. 4

    Citarella Greenwich

    Greenwich, CT · Gourmet market

    Usually has 69 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Corbarino tomatoes, Raschera, Fregola and Cotechino

  5. 5

    T&J Supermarket

    East Haven, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 55 of the 201

    Including Stelline, Smoked scamorza, Torrone and Perciatelli

Best in Queens5

  1. 1

    Iavarone Bros Maspeth

    Maspeth, Queens · Italian grocery

    Usually has 104 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Agnolotti, Cannelloni, Montasio and Cotechino

  2. 2

    Made In Eatalia Salumeria

    Glendale, Queens · Italian salumeria

    Usually has 66 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Galbanino, Gianduja paste, Cannelloni and Montasio

  3. 3

    North Shore Farms Whitestone

    Whitestone, Queens · Supermarket

    Usually has 85 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Romano beans (flat beans), Caciocavallo, Tagliolini and Smoked scamorza

  4. 4

    Foodtown Fresh Meadows

    Fresh Meadows, Queens · Supermarket · and 7 other branches

    Usually has 88 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Zucchini flowers, Malloreddus, Saba and Wild boar

  5. 5

    Food Cellar & Co 47th Rd

    Long Island City, Queens · Supermarket

    Usually has 78 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Strangozzi, Cappelletti, Bottarga and Truffle sauce

Best in the Hudson Valley5

  1. 1

    DeCicco & Sons Brewster

    Brewster, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 102 of the 201 · sometimes 12 more

    Including Bigoli, Corbarino tomatoes, Pici and Fregola

  2. 2

    Old World Food Market

    Nyack, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 85 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Monte Veronese, Ubriaco, Traditional balsamic vinegar and Wild boar

  3. 3

    Price Chopper Chatham

    Chatham, NY · Supermarket · and 6 other branches

    Usually has 53 of the 201 · sometimes 4 more

    Including Mezze maniche, Paccheri, Dandelion greens and Porcini mushrooms

  4. 4

    Acme Mahopac

    Mahopac, NY · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 60 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Tagliatelle, Pistachio cream, Radiatori and 00 flour

  5. 5

    ShopRite 20 Lloyds Ln

    Middletown, NY · Supermarket · and 21 other branches

    Usually has 60 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Perciatelli, Whelks, Cavatelli and Tinned tuna belly

Best in Westchester5

  1. 1

    Uncle Giuseppe's Yorktown Heights

    Yorktown Heights, NY · Italian grocery

    Usually has 115 of the 201 · sometimes 15 more

    Including Lardo, Gianduja paste, Caciotta and White truffles

  2. 2

    DeCicco & Sons Scarsdale

    Scarsdale, NY · Supermarket · and 10 other branches

    Usually has 114 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more

    Including Bigoli, Pici, Raschera and Datterini tomatoes

  3. 3

    North Shore Farms Mamaroneck

    Mamaroneck, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 78 of the 201 · sometimes 7 more

    Including Fresh anchovies, Romano beans (flat beans), Tagliolini and Smoked scamorza

  4. 4

    Country Markets

    Eastchester, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 81 of the 201

    Including Salt-packed capers, Romanesco, Strozzapreti and Artichoke paste

  5. 5

    DeCicco & Sons Harrison

    Harrison, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 12 more

    Including Raschera, Fregola, Trofie and Caciocavallo

Best in the Bronx5

  1. 1

    Big Deal Supermarket

    Morris Park, Bronx · Supermarket

    Usually has 72 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Salt-packed capers, Smoked scamorza, Tubetti and Mafaldine

  2. 2

    Teitel Brothers

    Belmont, Bronx · Italian grocery

    Usually has 31 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Pantelleria capers, Citron (fresh), Saba and Caciocavallo

  3. 3

    Key Food 1791 Walton Ave

    Mount Hope, Bronx · Supermarket · and 22 other branches

    Usually has 57 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Calamarata, Guanciale, Stracciatella and Bresaola

  4. 4

    Dominick's Market City Island

    City Island, Bronx · Supermarket

    Usually has 57 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Tubetti, Calamarata, Mezze maniche and Perciatelli

  5. 5

    Food Bazaar E 161st St

    Concourse, Bronx · Supermarket · and 10 other branches

    Usually has 65 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more

    Including Bel Paese, Fresh cuttlefish, Spaghettoni and Gilt-head bream

Best in Staten Island5

  1. 1

    La Bella Marketplace Tottenville

    Tottenville, Staten Island · Supermarket

    Usually has 109 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Tuma (persa), Canestrato, Caciotta and Raschera

  2. 2

    Top Tomato

    Eltingville, Staten Island · Produce market

    Usually has 67 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Agnolotti, Ubriaco, Romano beans (flat beans) and Salt-packed capers

  3. 3

    Met Food Hylan Blvd

    Dongan Hills, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 70 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Caciocavallo, San Marzano DOP tomatoes, Anellini and Tubetti

  4. 4

    Freddies Salumeria & Pork Store

    Eltingville, Staten Island · Italian salumeria

    Usually has 38 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Pantelleria capers, Stelline, Caciocavallo and San Marzano DOP tomatoes

  5. 5

    ShopRite 2656 Hylan Blvd

    Richmond Town, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 70 of the 201 · sometimes 4 more

    Including Salt-packed capers, White balsamic vinegar, Anellini and Tubetti

Best in upstate New York5

  1. 1

    Honest Weight Food Co-op

    Albany, NY · Natural foods market

    Usually has 77 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Mostarda di Cremona, Fregola, Ubriaco and Garganelli

  2. 2

    Whole Foods Albany

    Albany, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 53 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more

    Including Busiate, 'Nduja, Truffle butter and Fontina Val d'Aosta

  3. 3

    Hannaford Voorheesville

    Voorheesville, NY · Supermarket · and 9 other branches

    Usually has 59 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Finocchiona, Bresaola, Pistachio cream and Casarecce

  4. 4

    ALDI Latham

    Latham, NY · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 25 of the 201

    Including Spaghetti alla chitarra, Speck, Profiteroles and Bucatini

  5. 5

    Walmart Albany

    Albany, NY · Department store · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 26 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more

    Including Mussels, Marzipan & almond paste, Farro and Manicotti

Italian ingredients we track201

Herbs & fresh produce

Pastes, sauces & condiments

Spices & seasonings

Chiles

Dried goods

Pickles & ferments

Fish & seafood

Pantry

Flours & baking

Snacks, sweets & convenience

Meat, eggs & dairy

Cheese

Drinks & bar

Noodles & pasta

Rice, grains & pulses

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there