European
The basics are everywhere. Regional cheeses like Monte Veronese, gianduja paste, black truffles and shapes like pici are where a specialty shop earns its keep.
Best stocked for Italian ingredients: Eataly Flatiron (Flatiron District, Manhattan), Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana (Ridgefield, NJ) and Tavola Italian Market (Cobble Hill, Brooklyn).
Plum tomatoes from near Naples, sweet and low in acid, for sauces and pizza.
At Eataly Flatiron, Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana and more
Finely milled flour for pizza dough and fresh pasta.
At Eataly Flatiron, Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana and more
Short, starchy grain such as arborio or carnaroli for creamy risotto.
At Eataly Flatiron, Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana and more
Sharp, salty sheep's milk cheese grated over pasta like cacio e pepe and carbonara.
At Eataly Flatiron, Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana and more
Hard, nutty cow's milk cheese grated onto pasta, risotto and soups.
At Eataly Flatiron, Tavola Italian Market and more
Cured pork jowl that renders its fat for carbonara and amatriciana.
At Eataly Flatiron, Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana and more
Coarse durum flour for dried pasta, gnocchi and bread.
At Eataly Flatiron, Piccolo's Gastronomia Italiana and more
Usually has 129 of the 201 · sometimes 18 more
Including Taggiasca olive paste, Tajarin, Corzetti and Trenette
Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 26 more
Including Galbanino, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Sedani and Pantelleria capers
Usually has 72 of the 201 · sometimes 17 more
Including Culatello, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Lardo and Fennel pollen
Usually has 79 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Balsamic jelly, Colatura di alici, Castelrosso and Castelmagno
Usually has 104 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more
Including Agnolotti, Cannelloni, Montasio and Cotechino
By area: New Jersey · Brooklyn · Long Island · Manhattan · Connecticut · Queens · the Hudson Valley · Westchester · the Bronx · Staten Island · upstate New York
Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 26 more
Including Galbanino, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Sedani and Pantelleria capers
Usually has 123 of the 201 · sometimes 10 more
Including Strangozzi, Gianduja paste, Caciotta and Pici
Usually has 88 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Agnolotti, Scialatielli, Ubriaco and Garganelli
Usually has 62 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more
Including Ligurian walnut sauce, Castelfranco radicchio, Bottarga and Citron (fresh)
Usually has 92 of the 201
Including Cannelloni, Stracchino, Garganelli and Salt-packed capers
Usually has 72 of the 201 · sometimes 17 more
Including Culatello, Piennolo del Vesuvio, Lardo and Fennel pollen
Usually has 103 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Raschera, Cannelloni, Datterini tomatoes and Squid ink
Usually has 79 of the 201
Including White anchovies, Pantelleria capers, Scialatielli and Montasio
Usually has 91 of the 201 · sometimes 11 more
Including Jimmy Nardello peppers, Salt-packed capers, Saba and Wild boar
Usually has 76 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Trofie, Busiate, 'Nduja and Robiola
Usually has 122 of the 201 · sometimes 19 more
Including Gianduja paste, Caciotta, Pici and Scialatielli
Usually has 102 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more
Including Pantelleria capers, Cannelloni, Montasio and Cotechino
Usually has 96 of the 201 · sometimes 6 more
Including Cannelloni, Montasio, Cotechino and Veal breast
Usually has 64 of the 201
Including Bavette, Salt-packed capers, Stelline and Caciocavallo
Usually has 129 of the 201 · sometimes 18 more
Including Taggiasca olive paste, Tajarin, Corzetti and Trenette
Usually has 79 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Balsamic jelly, Colatura di alici, Castelrosso and Castelmagno
Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including White anchovies, Bottarga, Fregola and Garganelli
Usually has 38 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more
Including Piennolo del Vesuvio, Datterini tomatoes, Salt-packed capers and Saba
Usually has 84 of the 201 · sometimes 4 more
Including Bergamot, White truffles, Datterini tomatoes and Squid ink
Usually has 94 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more
Including Raschera, Trofie, Caciocavallo and San Marzano DOP tomatoes
Usually has 55 of the 201 · sometimes 29 more
Including Malloreddus, Stelline, White balsamic vinegar and Fontina Val d'Aosta
Usually has 69 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more
Including Corbarino tomatoes, Raschera, Fregola and Cotechino
Usually has 55 of the 201
Including Stelline, Smoked scamorza, Torrone and Perciatelli
Usually has 104 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more
Including Agnolotti, Cannelloni, Montasio and Cotechino
Usually has 66 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Galbanino, Gianduja paste, Cannelloni and Montasio
Usually has 85 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Romano beans (flat beans), Caciocavallo, Tagliolini and Smoked scamorza
Usually has 88 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Zucchini flowers, Malloreddus, Saba and Wild boar
Usually has 78 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Strangozzi, Cappelletti, Bottarga and Truffle sauce
Usually has 102 of the 201 · sometimes 12 more
Including Bigoli, Corbarino tomatoes, Pici and Fregola
Usually has 85 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Monte Veronese, Ubriaco, Traditional balsamic vinegar and Wild boar
Usually has 53 of the 201 · sometimes 4 more
Including Mezze maniche, Paccheri, Dandelion greens and Porcini mushrooms
Usually has 60 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more
Including Tagliatelle, Pistachio cream, Radiatori and 00 flour
Usually has 60 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Perciatelli, Whelks, Cavatelli and Tinned tuna belly
Usually has 115 of the 201 · sometimes 15 more
Including Lardo, Gianduja paste, Caciotta and White truffles
Usually has 114 of the 201 · sometimes 5 more
Including Bigoli, Pici, Raschera and Datterini tomatoes
Usually has 78 of the 201 · sometimes 7 more
Including Fresh anchovies, Romano beans (flat beans), Tagliolini and Smoked scamorza
Usually has 81 of the 201
Including Salt-packed capers, Romanesco, Strozzapreti and Artichoke paste
Usually has 92 of the 201 · sometimes 12 more
Including Raschera, Fregola, Trofie and Caciocavallo
Usually has 72 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Salt-packed capers, Smoked scamorza, Tubetti and Mafaldine
Usually has 31 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more
Including Pantelleria capers, Citron (fresh), Saba and Caciocavallo
Usually has 57 of the 201 · sometimes 3 more
Including Calamarata, Guanciale, Stracciatella and Bresaola
Usually has 57 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Tubetti, Calamarata, Mezze maniche and Perciatelli
Usually has 65 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more
Including Bel Paese, Fresh cuttlefish, Spaghettoni and Gilt-head bream
Usually has 109 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Tuma (persa), Canestrato, Caciotta and Raschera
Usually has 67 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Agnolotti, Ubriaco, Romano beans (flat beans) and Salt-packed capers
Usually has 70 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Caciocavallo, San Marzano DOP tomatoes, Anellini and Tubetti
Usually has 38 of the 201 · sometimes 1 more
Including Pantelleria capers, Stelline, Caciocavallo and San Marzano DOP tomatoes
Usually has 70 of the 201 · sometimes 4 more
Including Salt-packed capers, White balsamic vinegar, Anellini and Tubetti
Usually has 77 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Mostarda di Cremona, Fregola, Ubriaco and Garganelli
Usually has 53 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more
Including Busiate, 'Nduja, Truffle butter and Fontina Val d'Aosta
Usually has 59 of the 201 · sometimes 2 more
Including Finocchiona, Bresaola, Pistachio cream and Casarecce
Usually has 25 of the 201
Including Spaghetti alla chitarra, Speck, Profiteroles and Bucatini
Usually has 26 of the 201 · sometimes 9 more
Including Mussels, Marzipan & almond paste, Farro and Manicotti