Staten Island
7 stores in Eltingville are on our list. Best stocked: Stop & Shop 4343 Amboy Rd, Top Tomato and ALDI 3285 Richmond Ave.
Good for: Italian
Usually has 311 hard-to-find ingredients
Including Kissabel Rouge apples, Branston Pickle, Piquillo peppers and Pad thai paste
Usually has 251 hard-to-find ingredients
Including Agnolotti, Huazontle, Ubriaco and Romano beans (flat beans)
Usually has 92 hard-to-find ingredients
Including Christstollen, Jaffa Cakes, Appenzeller and Spaghetti alla chitarra
Usually has 54 hard-to-find ingredients
Including Pantelleria capers, Kecap manis, Stelline and Caciocavallo
Usually has 18 hard-to-find ingredients
Including Cavatelli, Pappardelle, Manicotti and Gnocchi
Usually has 8 hard-to-find ingredients
Including Montasio, Cotechino, Caciocavallo and San Marzano DOP tomatoes