
Pickles & ferments
Stores that usually have Guava paste: Amarh Market (Hackettstown, NJ), America's Food Basket (New Britain, CT), Antillana Superfoods W 207th St (Inwood, Manhattan) and 994 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 204 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
A firm, sliceable block of cooked guava and sugar, eaten with cheese and baked into pastelitos across Latin America and Brazil.
Also sold as goiabada, pasta de guayaba, guava cheese, bocadillo de guayaba, guava bar, ate de guayaba.
In Brazilian, Caribbean, Colombian & Venezuelan, Colombian and Puerto Rican cooking.
Substitute apple butter.
Might also be at 88 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).