The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Caribbean

Caribbean

Puerto Rican ingredients

Sofrito comes first, so the herbs matter: ají dulce (a sweet, barely hot pepper), culantro and achiote oil. Pique is the hot sauce on the table.

Best stocked for Puerto Rican ingredients: Compare Foods Boston Rd (Morrisania, Bronx), Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza (Lower East Side, Manhattan) and Dan's Supermarket W 185th St (Washington Heights, Manhattan).

Puerto Rican pantry essentials10

Best stores for Puerto Rican ingredients5

  1. 1

    Compare Foods Boston Rd

    Morrisania, Bronx · Supermarket · and 17 other branches

    Usually has 26 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

  2. 2

    Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza

    Lower East Side, Manhattan · Produce market

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh) and Yams

  3. 3

    Dan's Supermarket W 185th St

    Washington Heights, Manhattan · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop

  4. 4

    Supremo Food Market Jersey City

    Jersey City, NJ · Latin American supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Yams

  5. 5

    Spring Valley Supermarket

    Spring Valley, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 17 of the 30 · sometimes 4 more

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Yams and Soursop

By area: New Jersey · Brooklyn · Long Island · Queens · Manhattan · Connecticut · the Bronx · the Hudson Valley · Westchester · Staten Island · upstate New York

Best in New Jersey5

  1. 1

    Supremo Food Market Jersey City

    Jersey City, NJ · Latin American supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Yams

  2. 2

    Extra Supermarket

    Jersey City, NJ · Supermarket · and 6 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Yams

  3. 3

    City Supermarket

    Newark, NJ · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Yams

  4. 4

    Food Universe

    Paterson, NJ · Supermarket

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds and Soursop

  5. 5

    Universal Supermarket

    Paterson, NJ · Supermarket

    Usually has 21 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Achiote oil, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds

Best in Brooklyn5

  1. 1

    Bravo Supermarket E 93rd St

    East Flatbush, Brooklyn · Supermarket · and 11 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Culantro (fresh)

  2. 2

    City Fresh Market 6th Ave

    Sunset Park, Brooklyn · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

  3. 3

    Sea Town Fish & Meat Market

    Bushwick, Brooklyn · Fish and meat market

    Usually has 13 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Feet & trotters, Passionfruit and Calabaza

  4. 4

    Ideal Food Basket Brooklyn Ave

    East Flatbush, Brooklyn · Supermarket · and 12 other branches

    Usually has 26 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

  5. 5

    America's Food Basket Rockaway Pkwy

    Canarsie, Brooklyn · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

Best on Long Island5

  1. 1

    Brentwood Market

    Brentwood, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

  2. 2

    Bravo Supermarket Central Islip

    Central Islip, NY · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds and Soursop

  3. 3

    CTown Uniondale

    Uniondale, NY · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop

  4. 4

    Key Food 935 Rosedale Rd

    Valley Stream, NY · Supermarket · and 8 other branches

    Usually has 23 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds

  5. 5

    Ideal Food Basket Baldwin

    Baldwin, NY · Supermarket · and 3 other branches

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Mamey sapote, Yams and Annatto seeds

Best in Queens5

  1. 1

    Trade Fair 89-02 37th Ave

    Jackson Heights, Queens · Supermarket · and 8 other branches

    Usually has 25 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

  2. 2

    SuperFresh Seneca Ave

    Ridgewood, Queens · Supermarket · and 7 other branches

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds

  3. 3

    CTown 98-02 Jamaica Ave

    Woodhaven, Queens · Supermarket · and 22 other branches

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

  4. 4

    Ideal Food Basket Corona Ave

    Corona, Queens · Supermarket

    Usually has 22 of the 30 · sometimes 3 more

    Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Yams

  5. 5

    Farmbria by Food Bazaar

    Cambria Heights, Queens · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

Best in Manhattan5

  1. 1

    Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza

    Lower East Side, Manhattan · Produce market

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh) and Yams

  2. 2

    Dan's Supermarket W 185th St

    Washington Heights, Manhattan · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop

  3. 3

    Associated Extra Jumbo Broadway

    Washington Heights, Manhattan · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 19 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Achiote oil, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Salt cod

  4. 4

    SuperFresh St Nicholas Ave

    Washington Heights, Manhattan · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 19 of the 30

    Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

  5. 5

    Big Apple Market

    Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

Best in Connecticut5

  1. 1

    Key Food Bridgeport

    Bridgeport, CT · Supermarket · and 8 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop

  2. 2

    America's Food Basket

    New Britain, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Puerto Rican pique, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Annatto seeds

  3. 3

    CTown 1744 Park St

    Hartford, CT · Supermarket · and 7 other branches

    Usually has 19 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Achiote oil, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

  4. 4

    Save A Lot Bridgeport

    Bridgeport, CT · Supermarket · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 19 of the 30

    Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

  5. 5

    Gala Foods Bridgeport East Main

    Bridgeport, CT · Supermarket

    Usually has 21 of the 30

    Including Yams, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

Best in the Bronx5

  1. 1

    Compare Foods Boston Rd

    Morrisania, Bronx · Supermarket · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 26 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote

  2. 2

    City Fresh Market Valentine Ave

    Fordham, Bronx · Supermarket

    Usually has 21 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Yams, Annatto seeds and Soursop

  3. 3

    Food Universe Randall Ave

    Clason Point, Bronx · Supermarket · and 19 other branches

    Usually has 23 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds

  4. 4

    Shop Fresh Food Marketplace

    Concourse, Bronx · Supermarket · and 7 other branches

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce and Mamey sapote

  5. 5

    Bravo Supermarket W Burnside Ave

    Tremont, Bronx · Supermarket · and 6 other branches

    Usually has 22 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop

Best in the Hudson Valley5

  1. 1

    Spring Valley Supermarket

    Spring Valley, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 17 of the 30 · sometimes 4 more

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Yams and Soursop

  2. 2

    Ideal Food Basket Haverstraw

    Haverstraw, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 19 of the 30

    Including Mamey sapote, Yams, Annatto seeds and Soursop

  3. 3

    Garden Fresh Market

    Spring Valley, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 23 of the 30

    Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Scotch bonnets, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

  4. 4

    Save A Lot Newburgh

    Newburgh, NY · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 18 of the 30

    Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

  5. 5

    ShopRite Garnerville

    Garnerville, NY · Supermarket · and 21 other branches

    Usually has 21 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

Best in Westchester5

  1. 1

    Peekskill Supermarket

    Peekskill, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce and Mamey sapote

  2. 2

    New Rochelle Farms

    New Rochelle, NY · Produce market

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

  3. 3

    Save A Lot Peekskill

    Peekskill, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 18 of the 30

    Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

  4. 4

    Food Bazaar Mount Vernon

    Mount Vernon, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 25 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

  5. 5

    Ideal Fresh Market

    Yonkers, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 19 of the 30

    Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Annatto seeds

Best in Staten Island5

  1. 1

    Food Bazaar Forest Ave

    Graniteville, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 24 of the 30

    Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)

  2. 2

    Food Dynasty (Key Food)

    Rosebank, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 6 other branches

    Usually has 20 of the 30

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Yams and Annatto seeds

  3. 3

    Associated Marketplace Broad St

    Clifton, Staten Island · Supermarket

    Usually has 17 of the 30

    Including Culantro (fresh), Guava, Feet & trotters and Guava paste

  4. 4

    CTown 1234 Castleton Ave

    West Brighton, Staten Island · Supermarket · and 1 other branch

    Usually has 20 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop

  5. 5

    SuperFresh Manor Rd

    Castleton Corners, Staten Island · Supermarket

    Usually has 20 of the 30

    Including Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava

Best in upstate New York5

  1. 1

    Walmart Albany

    Albany, NY · Department store · and 4 other branches

    Usually has 7 of the 30 · sometimes 7 more

    Including Guava paste, Green pigeon peas, Adobo seasoning and Cream of coconut

  2. 2

    Hannaford Voorheesville

    Voorheesville, NY · Supermarket · and 9 other branches

    Usually has 8 of the 30 · sometimes 2 more

    Including Chayote, Taro & malanga, Plantains and Green pigeon peas

  3. 3

    BJ's Albany

    Albany, NY · Supermarket

    Usually has 4 of the 30

    Including Queso de freír, Cubanelle peppers and Sazón

  4. 4

    Target Colonie

    Colonie, NY · Department store · and 2 other branches

    Usually has 3 of the 30

    Including Plantains, Recaíto and Sazón

  5. 5

    Honest Weight Food Co-op

    Albany, NY · Natural foods market

    Usually has 4 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more

    Including Mamey sapote, Passionfruit, Chayote and Sazón

Puerto Rican ingredients we track30

Herbs & fresh produce

Pastes, sauces & condiments

Spices & seasonings

Chiles

Pickles & ferments

Fish & seafood

Pantry

Meat, eggs & dairy

Cheese

Drinks & bar

Rice, grains & pulses

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there