Sofrito comes first, so the herbs matter: ají dulce (a sweet, barely hot pepper), culantro and achiote oil. Pique is the hot sauce on the table.
Best stocked for Puerto Rican ingredients: Compare Foods Boston Rd (Morrisania, Bronx), Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza (Lower East Side, Manhattan) and Dan's Supermarket W 185th St (Washington Heights, Manhattan).
Green cooking base of culantro, peppers and herbs, for nearly every stew and rice dish.
At most supermarkets
Seasoning packets with annatto and garlic that color and flavor rice and beans.
At most supermarkets
All-purpose garlic and oregano seasoning rubbed on meat before roasting or frying.
At most supermarkets
Long, serrated herb with strong cilantro flavor, used in sofrito and stews.
At Compare Foods Boston Rd, Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza and more
Small, mild peppers chopped into sofrito and beans.
At Compare Foods Boston Rd, Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza and more
Oil infused with annatto seeds, used to color and flavor rice and stews.
At Compare Foods Boston Rd, Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza and more
Green peas cooked into arroz con gandules, the holiday rice dish.
At most supermarkets
Starchy banana fried green for tostones and mofongo or ripe for maduros.
At most supermarkets
Dried cod soaked and cooked into bacalao stews and salads.
At Compare Foods Boston Rd, Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza and more
Firm sweet paste sliced with white cheese or baked into pastries.
At Compare Foods Boston Rd, Luna Brothers Fruit Plaza and more
Usually has 26 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh) and Yams
Usually has 21 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Yams
Usually has 17 of the 30 · sometimes 4 more
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Yams and Soursop
By area: New Jersey · Brooklyn · Long Island · Queens · Manhattan · Connecticut · the Bronx · the Hudson Valley · Westchester · Staten Island · upstate New York
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Yams
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Yams
Usually has 21 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Achiote oil, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 13 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Feet & trotters, Passionfruit and Calabaza
Usually has 26 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 23 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Mamey sapote, Yams and Annatto seeds
Usually has 25 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 22 of the 30 · sometimes 3 more
Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Yams
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh) and Yams
Usually has 21 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 19 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Achiote oil, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Salt cod
Usually has 19 of the 30
Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 21 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Puerto Rican pique, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Annatto seeds
Usually has 19 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Achiote oil, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 19 of the 30
Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 21 of the 30
Including Yams, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 26 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Achiote oil and Mamey sapote
Usually has 21 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Yams, Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 23 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Mamey sapote, Culantro (fresh) and Annatto seeds
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce and Mamey sapote
Usually has 22 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 17 of the 30 · sometimes 4 more
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Yams and Soursop
Usually has 19 of the 30
Including Mamey sapote, Yams, Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 23 of the 30
Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Scotch bonnets, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 21 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Spearmint (yerba buena), Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce and Mamey sapote
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 18 of the 30
Including Mamey sapote, Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 25 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 19 of the 30
Including Ají dulce, Achiote oil, Mamey sapote and Annatto seeds
Usually has 24 of the 30
Including Scotch bonnets, Ají dulce, Mamey sapote and Culantro (fresh)
Usually has 20 of the 30
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Yams and Annatto seeds
Usually has 17 of the 30
Including Culantro (fresh), Guava, Feet & trotters and Guava paste
Usually has 20 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Achiote oil, Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds and Soursop
Usually has 20 of the 30
Including Culantro (fresh), Annatto seeds, Soursop and Guava
Usually has 7 of the 30 · sometimes 7 more
Including Guava paste, Green pigeon peas, Adobo seasoning and Cream of coconut
Usually has 8 of the 30 · sometimes 2 more
Including Chayote, Taro & malanga, Plantains and Green pigeon peas
Usually has 4 of the 30 · sometimes 1 more
Including Mamey sapote, Passionfruit, Chayote and Sazón