The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Stores

Suffolk County, NY

Specialty grocers in Shirley

6 stores in Shirley are on our list. Best stocked: Stop & Shop Shirley, Gala Fresh Farms and King Kullen Shirley.

Good for: Peruvian

Stores in Shirley6

  • Stop & Shop Shirley

    Supermarket · 999 Montauk Hwy

    Usually has 363 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Mint sauce, Piquillo peppers, Tinned octopus and Thai basil

  • Gala Fresh Farms

    Produce market · 803 Montauk Hwy A

    Usually has 287 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Pickled tomato peppers, Queso costeño, Cueritos and Seckel pears

  • King Kullen Shirley

    Supermarket · 405 William Floyd Pkwy

    Usually has 231 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Smoked pork neck, Spätzle, Smoked scamorza and Anellini

  • Lidl Shirley

    Supermarket · 800 Montauk Hwy

    Usually has 107 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Weisswurst, White asparagus, Santa Claus melon and Sour cherries

  • ALDI Shirley

    Supermarket · 855 Montauk Hwy

    Usually has 95 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Christstollen, Jaffa Cakes, Appenzeller and Spaghetti alla chitarra

  • Happy Steer Meat Market

    Butcher · 146 Mastic Blvd W

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

    Including Black pudding

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there