The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Stores

Brooklyn

Specialty grocers in Sheepshead Bay

28 stores in Sheepshead Bay are on our list. Best stocked: Okka Foods Market, Stop & Shop 1710 Avenue Y and Portokali Gourmet Market.

Good for: Caucasus & Central Asian · Balkan · Turkish · Russian, Ukrainian & Baltic

Stores in Sheepshead Bay28

  • Okka Foods Market

    Eastern European supermarket · 1524 Kings Hwy

    Usually has 481 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Jonjoli, Gavottes (crêpes dentelle), Túró Rudi and Svanetian salt

  • Stop & Shop 1710 Avenue Y

    Supermarket · 1710 Avenue Y

    Usually has 387 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Straw mushrooms, Piquillo peppers, Pad thai paste and Tinned octopus

  • Portokali Gourmet Market

    Turkish grocery · 1519 Sheepshead Bay Rd

    Usually has 331 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Svanetian salt, Pişmaniye, Erişte and Pine cone jam

  • Cherry Hill Gourmet

    Eastern European supermarket · 1901 Emmons Ave

    Usually has 269 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Pine cone jam, Satsebeli, Khmeli suneli and Leatherwood honey

  • CTown 1709 Ave U

    Supermarket · 1709 Avenue U

    Usually has 163 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cumberland sausage, Ruby Frost apples, Choclo and Lychee

  • ALDI 3785 Nostrand Ave

    Supermarket · 3785 Nostrand Ave

    Usually has 90 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Jaffa Cakes, Appenzeller, Spaghetti alla chitarra and Gloucester

  • Target Brooklyn Midwood

    Department store · 1712 E 14th St

    Usually has 65 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Hello Panda, Sanding sugar, Tapioca pearls and Standing rib roast (prime rib)

  • Ocean Bay Market

    Chinese grocery · 2424 Coney Island Ave

    Usually has 36 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cincalok, Green radish, Taro shoots and Duck gizzards

  • OLMA Caviar Boutique

    Caviar shop · 2222 Avenue X

    Usually has 30 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Bottarga, Chanterelles, Trout roe and Cod liver

  • NetCost Market 3100 Ocean Ave

    Eastern European supermarket · 3100 Ocean Ave

    Usually has 23 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Kabanos, Smoked sprats, Caviar and Turkey wings

  • Shing Hing Food

    Chinese grocery · 1811 Ave U

    Usually has 22 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Ching po leung soup mix, Dried oysters, Fish maw and Dang shen

  • NetCost Market 2257 E 16th St

    Eastern European supermarket · 2257 E 16th St

    Usually has 19 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Kabanos, Smoked sprats, Caviar and Turkey wings

  • Sheepshead Bay Marketplace

    Eastern European supermarket · 1717 Ave Z

    Usually has 8 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Romanesco, Kiwano, Coloured cauliflower and Jackfruit

  • Golden Super Market

    Halal butcher · 3838 Nostrand Ave

    Usually has 6 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Hearts, Necks, Feet & trotters and Veal

  • Green Forest

    Eastern European supermarket · 1717 Kings Hwy

    Usually has 5 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Vegan cheese and Kimchi

  • Star Market

    Eastern European supermarket · 1805 Ave U

    Usually has 5 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Wonton noodles, Dried shrimp, Enoki mushrooms and Lobster

  • Tashkent Supermarket Coney Island Ave

    Central Asian and Russian supermarket · 2828 Coney Island Ave

    Usually has 5 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Ryazhenka and Tomahawk steak

  • Avenue U Fish Market

    Fish market · 2704 Ave U

    Usually has 3 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Swordfish, Fresh squid and Lobster

  • Chang Fa Food Market

    Chinese supermarket · 1418 Avenue U

    Usually has 3 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Frogs & frog legs, Glutinous rice and Specialty bananas

  • Cherry Hill Gourmet Avenue U

    Gourmet market · 2613 Avenue U

    Usually has 2 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Speculaas

  • A&C Seafood & Meat Market

    Chinese supermarket · 1237 Avenue U

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

    Including Octopus

  • Domino Supermarket

    Eastern European supermarket · 1824 Kings Hwy

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

    Including Smoked sprats

  • G&S Salumeria & Pork Store

    Italian pork store · 2611 Ave U

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

    Including Dry-aged beef

  • Chalouh Market

    Middle Eastern grocery · 718 Ave U

  • Forces of Nature

    Natural foods market · 1608 Sheepshead Bay Rd

  • Mimino International Food

    Eastern European grocery · 2969 Ocean Ave

  • New Easy Shop Supermarket

    Chinese supermarket · 1520 Avenue U

  • Sweet Island

    Eastern European grocery · 1214 Ave U

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there