The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Stores

Suffolk County, NY

Specialty grocers in Bay Shore

16 stores in Bay Shore are on our list. Best stocked: ShopRite Bay Shore, King Kullen Bay Shore and Gala Foods Bay Shore.

Stores in Bay Shore16

  • ShopRite Bay Shore

    Supermarket · 1905 Sunrise Hwy

    Usually has 308 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Stone crab, Mace (ground), Pea tips and Aura apples

  • King Kullen Bay Shore

    Supermarket · 834 Sunrise Hwy Gardiner Manor Ml

    Usually has 249 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Smoked pork neck, Spätzle, Anellini and Tubetti

  • Gala Foods Bay Shore

    Supermarket · 1819 5th Ave

    Usually has 240 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Pikliz, Mellocos, Mexican bay leaf and Guava leaves

  • Beverage Barn Bay Shore

    Beer distributor · 51 W Garfield St

    Usually has 137 hard-to-find ingredients

  • ALDI Bay Shore

    Supermarket · 1851 Sunrise Hwy

    Usually has 96 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Christstollen, Jaffa Cakes, Appenzeller and Spaghetti alla chitarra

  • Target Bay Shore

    Department store · 838 Sunrise Hwy

    Usually has 82 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Hello Panda, Hot Ones, Sanding sugar and Standing rib roast (prime rib)

  • Dairy City

    Supermarket · 42 Bay Shore Rd

    Usually has 76 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cara Cara oranges, Cotton Candy grapes, Blood oranges and Water chestnuts

  • Crown 1 Foods

    Supermarket · 85 Saxon Ave

    Usually has 63 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Cara Cara oranges, Cotton Candy grapes, Blood oranges and Water chestnuts

  • Naela's Mediterranean

    Middle Eastern grocery · 77 Howells Rd

    Usually has 24 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Mansaf spice, Lemon verbena, Dukkah and Mastic

  • Pineaire Fish Market

    Fish market · 140 Pine Aire Dr

    Usually has 2 hard-to-find ingredients

    Including Scup and Fresh scallops

  • Ayeza Halal Food & Grocery

    Middle Eastern grocery · 1535 Brentwood Rd

    Usually has 1 hard-to-find ingredient

    Including Atta

  • All Nation African Market

    African grocery · 1750 Sunrise Hwy

  • Depot Meat Market

    Butcher · 1669 5th Ave

  • La Tropical Market

    Latin American grocery · 1617 5th Ave 1st Floor

  • Select Meats

    Butcher · 1562 Brentwood Rd

  • Super Meat Market

    Butcher · 3 Candlewood Rd Ste 8

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there