
Meat, eggs & dairy
Stores that usually have Mutton: Aqui Market of Califon (Califon, NJ), Big Apple Market W 16th St (Chelsea, Manhattan), Butcher's Corner (Florida, NY) and 43 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 14 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
Meat from sheep over a year or so old, darker and more strongly flavored than lamb; for slow braises, curries, stews and roasts.
Also sold as mutton, hogget, mature sheep, mutton chops, mutton leg.
Meat from older sheep, stronger than lamb. In South Asian shops "mutton" usually means goat: that's the goat meat tile.
Substitute lamb shoulder (milder) or goat meat.