
Flours & baking
Stores that usually have Mexican vanilla: Bensonhurst Market (Brooklyn), BenZ's Gourmet (Crown Heights, Brooklyn), Brentwood Market (Brentwood, NY) and 84 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 80 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
Vanilla extract made in Mexico, often richer and spicier in flavor; some cheaper bottles are blended with synthetic vanillin.
Also sold as vainilla mexicana, mexican vanilla extract, Molina vanilla, Danncy, vainilla de papantla, papantla vanilla.
In Baking & pastry and Mexican cooking.
Substitute vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste.
Might also be at 352 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).