
Cheese
Stores that usually have Kefalotyri: Balady Market (Bay Ridge, Brooklyn), Big Apple Market (Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan), City Supermarket (Fairview, NJ) and 50 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 12 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
A hard, salty Greek sheep's or goat's milk cheese, sharp and tangy; for grating over pasta or frying as saganaki.
Also sold as kefalotiri, kefalograviera, κεφαλοτύρι, kefalotyri cheese.
In Greek cooking.
Substitute kasseri, Pecorino Romano or Parmesan.
Might also be at 152 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).