
Fish & seafood
Stores that usually have Jamaican butterfish: Farmbria by Food Bazaar (Cambria Heights, Queens), Food Bazaar 57th Ave (Corona, Queens), John's Farm Market Farmers Blvd (St. Albans, Queens) and 21 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 1 more store. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
Small reef fish prized in Jamaican cooking, usually fried or steamed whole with peppers.
Also sold as jamaican butterfish, jamaican butter fish, butterfish (jamaican), coney, coney fish, Cephalopholis fulva.
A Caribbean reef fish (usually the coney, a small grouper), mostly sold whole and frozen in West Indian shops. Not the Atlantic butterfish or escolar sometimes sold under the same name.
In Caribbean and Jamaican cooking.
Substitute pompano, jack fish or porgy.