The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Back to the index
Cotija

Cheese

Cotija

Stores that usually have Cotija: 3 Guys From Brooklyn (Dyker Heights, Brooklyn), Adam's IGA Supermarket (Milford, CT), Adam's Super Food Store (Deep River, CT) and 1454 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 72 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.

A hard, dry, salty Mexican cow's milk cheese named for a town in Michoacán; crumbled over elotes, beans, tacos and salads.

Also sold as queso cotija, cotija cheese, aged cotija.

In Mexican cooking.

Substitute feta, Parmesan or Romano.

Where to find it2232 stores

  • 3 Guys From Brooklyn

    Usually has itDyker Heights
    6502 Fort Hamilton Pkwy · Dyker Heights, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • 55 Fulton Market (Key Food)

    Usually has itFinancial District
    55 Fulton Street · Financial District, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme 125 18th St

    Usually has it2 productsJersey City
    125 18th St · Jersey City
    Acme 125 18th St on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme 300 S Lenola Rd

    Usually has itMaple Shade
    300 S Lenola Rd · Maple Shade
    Stocked at most Acme branches; this branch not checked
  • Acme 321 Stadium Plz

    Usually has itJersey City
    321 Stadium Plz · Jersey City
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Allendale

    Usually has it$7.99 eachAllendale
    45 De Mercurio Dr · Allendale
    Acme Allendale on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Barnegat

    Usually has it$7.99 eachBarnegat
    912 W Bay Ave · Barnegat
    Acme Barnegat on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Blairstown

    Usually has it2 productsBlairstown
    152 Route 94 · Blairstown
    Acme Blairstown on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Boonton

    Usually has itBoonton
    550 Myrtle Ave · Boonton
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Bordentown

    Usually has it$7.99 eachBordentown
    260 Dunns Mill Rd · Bordentown
    Acme - Dunns Mills Road on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Brewster

    Usually has itBrewster
    1511 Route 22 · Brewster
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Briarcliff Manor

    Usually has it$8.99 eachBriarcliff Manor
    1886 Pleasantville Rd · Briarcliff Manor
    Acme Briarcliff Manor on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Bronxville

    Usually has it2 productsBronxville
    12 Cedar St · Bronxville
    Acme Bronxville on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Browns Mills

    Usually has itBrowns Mills
    18 Broadway · Browns Mills
    Stocked at most Acme branches; this branch not checked
  • Acme Clark

    Usually has it$7.99 eachClark
    1060 Raritan Rd · Clark
    Acme Clark on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Denville

    Usually has it2 productsDenville
    123 E Main St · Denville
    Acme Denville on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Fair Haven

    Usually has it$7.99 eachFair Haven
    576 River Rd · Fair Haven
    Acme Fair Haven on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Fort Lee

    Usually has it$7.99 eachFort Lee
    2160 Lemoine Ave · Fort Lee
    Acme Fort Lee on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Freehold

    Usually has itFreehold
    3241 Us Hwy 9 · Freehold
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Goldens Bridge

    Usually has it$8.99 eachGoldens Bridge
    100 Route 22 · Goldens Bridge
    Acme Goldens Bridge on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Hamilton

    Usually has it$7.99 eachHamilton
    953 Route 33 · Hamilton
    Acme Hamilton on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Hoboken

    Usually has itHoboken
    614 Clinton St · Hoboken
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Hopewell Junction

    Usually has itHopewell Junction
    829 Rt 82 · Hopewell Junction
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Kenilworth

    Usually has it$7.99 eachKenilworth
    801 Kenilworth Blvd · Kenilworth
    Acme Kenilworth on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Lincroft

    Usually has it$7.99 eachLincroft
    616 Newman Springs Rd · Lincroft
    Acme Lincroft on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Little Silver

    Usually has it$7.99 eachLittle Silver
    507 Prospect Ave · Little Silver
    Acme Little Silver on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Long Beach Township

    Usually has itLong Beach Township
    9600 Beach Ave · Long Beach Township
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Mahopac

    Usually has it$6.99 eachMahopac
    272 Us Rt 6 · Mahopac
    Acme Mahopac on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Mahwah

    Usually has it$7.99 eachMahwah
    125 Franklin Tpke · Mahwah
    Acme Mahwah on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Manahawkin

    Usually has it$7.99 eachManahawkin
    609 E Bay Ave · Manahawkin
    Acme Manahawkin on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Maple Shade

    Usually has itMaple Shade
    41 W Main St · Maple Shade
    Stocked at most Acme branches; this branch not checked
  • Acme Medford

    Usually has it$7.99 eachMedford
    175 Route 70 · Medford
    Acme - Route 70 on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Midland Park

    Usually has it2 productsMidland Park
    136 Lake Ave · Midland Park
    Acme Midland Park on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Mohegan Lake

    Usually has itMohegan Lake
    3105 E Main St · Mohegan Lake
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Montclair

    Usually has it2 productsMontclair
    510 Valley Rd · Montclair
    Acme Montclair on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Mount Holly

    Usually has it$7.99 eachMount Holly
    531 High St · Mount Holly
    Acme - High Street on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme New Canaan

    Usually has itNew Canaan
    288 Elm St · New Canaan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme New Providence

    Usually has it2 productsNew Providence
    1260 Springfield Ave · New Providence
    Acme New Providence on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme New Rochelle

    Usually has itNew Rochelle
    23 Quaker Ridge Rd · New Rochelle
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Oak Ridge

    Usually has it$7.99 eachOak Ridge
    5774 Berkshire Valley Rd · Oak Ridge
    Acme Oak Ridge on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Old Bridge

    Usually has it$7.99 eachOld Bridge
    3500 Route 9 · Old Bridge
    Acme Old Bridge on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Patterson

    Usually has itPatterson
    3101 Rt 22 · Patterson
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Pleasant Valley

    Usually has it$6.49 eachPleasant Valley
    13 North Ave · Pleasant Valley
    Acme Pleasant Valley on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Port Chester

    Usually has it$6.49 eachPort Chester
    261 S Ridge St · Port Chester
    Acme Port Chester on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Randolph

    Usually has it$7.99 eachRandolph
    690 Millbrook Ave · Randolph
    Acme Randolph on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Riverside

    Usually has itRiverside
    1261 E Putnam Ave · Riverside
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Saddle Brook

    Usually has it2 productsSaddle Brook
    75 Mayhill St · Saddle Brook
    Acme Saddle Brook on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Seaside Heights

    Usually has it$7.99 eachSeaside Heights
    5 Ortley Plz · Seaside Heights
    Acme Seaside Heights on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Shrub Oak

    Usually has it$6.99 eachShrub Oak
    1366 E Main St · Shrub Oak
    Acme Shrub Oak on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Stamford

    Usually has itStamford
    1201 High Ridge Rd · Stamford
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Trenton

    Usually has it$7.99 eachTrenton
    4400 S Broad St · Trenton
    Acme Trenton on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Tuckerton

    Usually has it$7.99 eachTuckerton
    425 Us Hwy 9 · Tuckerton
    Acme Tuckerton on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Vernon

    Usually has it$7.99 eachVernon
    530 Route 515 · Vernon
    Acme Vernon on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme Wall Township

    Usually has it2 productsWall Township
    2007 Route 35 · Wall Township
    Acme Wall Township on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme Warren

    Usually has it$7.99 eachWarren
    177 Washington Valley Rd · Warren
    Acme Warren on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Acme West New York

    Usually has it$10.29 eachWest New York
    19-21 Ave At Port Imperial · West New York
    Acme West New York on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Acme White Plains

    Usually has it$6.99 eachWhite Plains
    103 Knollwood Rd · White Plains
    Acme White Plains on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Acme Willingboro

    Usually has itWillingboro
    23 Levitt Pkwy · Willingboro
    Stocked at most Acme branches; this branch not checked
  • Acme Yonkers

    Usually has itYonkers
    660 McLean Ave · Yonkers
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Acme Yorktown Heights

    Usually has it$6.99 eachYorktown Heights
    100 Triangle Shopping Center · Yorktown Heights
    Acme Yorktown Heights on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Adam's IGA Supermarket

    Usually has itMilford
    1391 New Haven Ave · Milford
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Adam's Super Food Store

    Usually has itDeep River
    193 Main St · Deep River
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Adams Fairacre Farms Wappinger

    Usually has itWappinger
    160 Old Post Rd · Wappinger
    Store website blog (2025): Wappinger unveils new cheese and coffee shop · checked Oct 24, 2026
  • Adams Hometown Market

    Usually has itPortland
    316 Marlborough St · Portland
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Amagansett IGA

    Usually has itAmagansett
    511 Montauk Hwy · Amagansett
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Amarh Market

    Usually has it$7.69Hackettstown
    116 E Plane St (07840) · Hackettstown
    Amarh Market's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 14, 2026
  • America's Food Basket

    Usually has it4 productsNew Britain
    250 Allen St · New Britain
    America's Food Basket New Britain on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • America's Food Basket Church Ave

    Usually has itEast Flatbush
    5311 Church Ave · East Flatbush, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • America's Food Basket Rockaway Pkwy

    Usually has itCanarsie
    1380 Rockaway Pkwy · Canarsie, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Antillana Superfood (Key Food)

    Usually has itMount Eden
    1339 Jerome Avenue · Bronx
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Antillana Superfood Jerome Ave

    Usually has itMount Hope
    1850 Jerome Ave · Mount Hope, Bronx
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Antillana Superfood Melrose Ave

    Usually has itMelrose
    616 Melrose Ave · Melrose, Bronx
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Antillana Superfoods W 207th St

    Usually has itInwood
    490 W 207th St · Inwood, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Apna Bazar Jackson Heights

    Usually has it$6.78Jackson Heights
    72-20 37th Ave · Jackson Heights, Queens
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Aqui Market

    Usually has itJersey City
    2-16 Garfield Ave · Jersey City
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Aqui Market Bridgewater

    Usually has itBridgewater
    617 e Main St · Bridgewater
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Aqui Market of Califon

    Usually has itCalifon
    431 County Rd 513 · Califon
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Associated Extra Jumbo Broadway

    Usually has itWashington Heights
    3788 Broadway · Washington Heights, Manhattan
    Extra Jumbo by Antillana's weekly circular (Oct 30-Nov 5, 2026) · checked Oct 30, 2026
  • Associated Fresh E Tremont Ave

    Usually has itMount Hope
    151 E Tremont Ave · Mount Hope, Bronx
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Associated Marketplace Broad St

    Usually has it3 productsClifton
    170 Broad St · Clifton, Staten Island
    Associated Marketplace Broad St on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Associated Supermarket Lorraine St

    Usually has itRed Hook
    58-60 Lorraine St · Red Hook, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Associated Supermarket Roosevelt Ave

    Usually has it5 productsWoodside
    59-15 Roosevelt Ave · Woodside, Queens
    Associated Supermarket Roosevelt Ave on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Associated Supermarket Seneca Ave

    Usually has itRidgewood
    333 Seneca Ave · Ridgewood, Queens
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Astoria Marketplace (Key Food)

    Usually has it3 productsAstoria
    31-18 24th Avenue · Astoria, Queens
    Astoria Marketplace (Key Food) on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Balducci's Greenwich

    Usually has itGreenwich
    1050 East Putnam Ave · Greenwich
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Balducci's Port Chester

    Usually has it$6.99 eachPort Chester
    144 S Ridge St · Port Chester
    Balducci's Port Chester on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Balducci's Scarsdale

    Usually has it$6.99 eachScarsdale
    15 Palmer Ave · Scarsdale
    Balducci's Scarsdale on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Bensonhurst Market

    Usually has it$7.99 eachBensonhurst
    7215 20th Ave · Bensonhurst, Brooklyn
    Bensonhurst Market on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 18, 2026
  • Best Farms

    Usually has itHicksville
    434 Jerusalem Ave · Hicksville
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Best Farms

    Usually has itWest Islip
    9 Udall Rd · West Islip
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Big Apple Market

    Usually has it2 productsHell's Kitchen
    577 9th Ave · Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan
    Big Apple Market on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Big Apple Market W 16th St

    Usually has itChelsea
    431 W 16th St · Chelsea, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Big Deal Supermarket

    Usually has itMorris Park
    1018 Morris Park Ave · Morris Park, Bronx
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Bishop's Orchards

    Usually has it2 productsGuilford
    1355 Boston Post Rd · Guilford
    Bishop's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Bob's Butcher and Basket

    Usually has it$5.99Willimantic
    422 Windham Rd · Willimantic
    Bob's Butcher and Basket's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 16, 2026
  • Bravo Supermarket 34th Ave

    Usually has it4 productsAstoria
    24-18 34th Ave · Astoria, Queens
    Bravo Supermarket 34th Ave on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Bravo Supermarket Bedford Ave

    Usually has it3 productsBedford-Stuyvesant
    991 Bedford Ave · Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn
    Bravo Supermarket Bedford Ave on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Bravo Supermarket Central Islip

    Usually has itCentral Islip
    174 Wheeler Rd · Central Islip
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Bravo Supermarket E 93rd St

    Usually has itEast Flatbush
    80 E 93rd St · East Flatbush, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Bravo Supermarket E Burnside Ave

    Usually has it3 productsTremont
    309 E Burnside Ave · Tremont, Bronx
    Bravo Supermarket E Burnside Ave on Mercato, in stock · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • And 2132 more stores.

Might also be at 259 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).

Brands spotted24

  • Whole Foods Market (365)In stock at Whole Foods Manhattan West, Whole Foods Chelsea, Whole Foods Bryant Park and 34 more
  • TalaveraIn stock at Uncle Giuseppe's Bohemia, Uncle Giuseppe's Greenvale, Uncle Giuseppe's Massapequa and 8 more; listed for 5 stores
  • Sole!In stock at Wegmans Astor Place, Wegmans West Harrison, Wegmans Lake Grove and 8 more; listed for 3 stores
  • CaciqueIn stock at Wegmans West Harrison, Wegmans Norwalk, Wegmans Ocean and 6 more; listed for 11 stores
  • Queso del ValleIn stock at Uncle Giuseppe's Bohemia, Uncle Giuseppe's Greenvale, Uncle Giuseppe's Massapequa and 4 more; listed for 5 stores
  • TropicalIn stock at Save A Lot Orange, Save A Lot Newark, Save A Lot Peekskill and 3 more
  • Los PortalesIn stock at Westside Market 2840 Broadway, La Bella Marketplace Dyker Heights, Fine Fare Myrtle Ave and 2 more; listed for 2 stores
  • El ViajeroIn stock at Save A Lot Newburgh, Save A Lot Newark, Save A Lot Port Jervis and 1 more
  • ColonnaIn stock at The Fresh Grocer Cedar Grove, The Fresh Grocer Washington Township, The Fresh Grocer Ringwood
  • BelGioiosoIn stock at Fine Fare Myrtle Ave, Key Food Nyack
  • Tia AngelitaIn stock at Save A Lot Newburgh, Save A Lot Orange
  • Amarh MarketIn stock at Amarh Market
  • FudIn stock at La Bella Marketplace Dyker Heights
  • La ChonaIn stock at Save A Lot Peekskill
  • NuestraIn stock at Bishop's Orchards
  • Nuestro QuesoIn stock at Willimantic Food Co-Op
  • Qué Gusto!In stock at La Bella Marketplace Tottenville
  • Quesos La RicuraIn stock at Key Food Nyack
  • Tropical CheeseListed for 192 stores
  • El MexicanoListed for 2 stores
  • Canyon BakehouseListed for 1 store
  • Familia Del NorteListed for 1 store
  • Marcelina'sListed for 1 store
  • Waterwitch GrocerListed for 1 store

Get it delivered

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there