The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Back to the index
Blue oyster mushrooms

Herbs & fresh produce

Blue oyster mushrooms

Stores that usually have Blue oyster mushrooms: Austin Organic Market (Forest Hills, Queens), Basil Bandwagon Natural Market (Clinton, NJ), Brooklyn Harvest Market (Williamsburg, Brooklyn) and 21 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 15 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.

Oyster mushrooms with steel-blue caps that fade to gray, meaty and mild, sautéed or roasted.

Also sold as blue oyster.

Substitute oyster mushrooms or cremini mushrooms.

Where to find it90 stores

  • Austin Organic Market

    Usually has itForest Hills
    72-48 Austin St · Forest Hills, Queens
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Basil Bandwagon Natural Market

    Usually has it$23.99Clinton
    38 Old Hwy 22 · Clinton
    Basil Bandwagon's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Basil Bandwagon Natural Market

    Usually has it$23.99Flemington
    276 Hwy 202/31 North · Flemington
    Basil Bandwagon's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Basil Bandwagon Natural Market

    Usually has it$23.99Lambertville
    239 N Union St · Lambertville
    Basil Bandwagon's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Brooklyn Harvest Market

    Usually has it$13.48Williamsburg
    25 N 5th St · Williamsburg, Brooklyn
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Ernest Klein (Key Food)

    Usually has it$9.43Midtown
    1366 6th Avenue · Midtown, Manhattan
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Foodtown 1291 Broadway

    Usually has it$13.69Bushwick
    1291 Broadway · Bushwick, Brooklyn
    DoorDash, listed in stock at this store · checked Oct 21, 2026
  • Jubilee Marketplace West St

    Usually has itGreenpoint
    145 West St · Greenpoint, Brooklyn
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Kimchee Market

    Usually has it$17.00Greenpoint
    191 Greenpoint Ave · Greenpoint, Brooklyn
    Kimchee Market's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • LifeThyme Natural Market

    Usually has it2 productsGreenwich Village
    410 6th Ave · Greenwich Village, Manhattan
    LifeThyme's online shop · checked Nov 15, 2026
  • Mushroom Direct

    Usually has it2 productsHollis
    91-36 182nd St · Hollis, Queens
    Mushroom Direct's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Spring Brook Farm & Greenhouse

    Usually has it$0.00Roscoe
    219 Rockland Rd · Roscoe
    Spring Brook Farm & Greenhouse's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 17, 2026
  • Wegmans Astor Place

    Usually has it$3.49East Village
    770 Broadway · East Village, Manhattan
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Bridgewater

    Usually has it$3.49Bridgewater
    724 Route 202 South · Bridgewater
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Brooklyn

    Usually has it$3.89Navy Yard
    21 Flushing Ave · Navy Yard, Brooklyn
    Uber Eats listing · checked Nov 19, 2026
  • Wegmans Lake Grove

    Usually has it$3.49Lake Grove
    3270 Middle Country Rd · Lake Grove
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Manalapan

    Usually has it$3.49Manalapan
    55 Us Hwy 9 · Manalapan
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Montvale

    Usually has it$3.49Montvale
    100 Farm Vw · Montvale
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Norwalk

    Usually has it$3.49Norwalk
    675 Connecticut Ave · Norwalk
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Ocean

    Usually has it$3.49Ocean
    1104 Hwy 35 S · Ocean
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Parsippany

    Usually has it$3.49Parsippany
    34 Sylvan Way · Parsippany
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Princeton

    Usually has it$3.49Princeton
    240 Nassau Park Blvd · Princeton
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans West Harrison

    Usually has it$3.49West Harrison
    106 Corporate Dr · West Harrison
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Wegmans Woodbridge

    Usually has it$3.49Woodbridge
    15 Woodbridge Ctr Dr · Woodbridge
    Wegmans website, in stock at this store · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • 57th Street Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itHell's Kitchen
    57th St. & 10th Ave. · Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan
    Morgiewicz Produce's Instagram · checked Jun 19, 2026
  • 82nd Street Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itUpper East Side
    82nd St. bet. 1st & York Aves · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Tivoli Mushrooms' website (Jack: at its Greenmarket stands) · checked Nov 8, 2026
  • Bronx Borough Hall Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itConcourse
    161st St. & Grand Concourse · Concourse, Bronx
    Morgiewicz Produce's Instagram · checked Jun 19, 2026
  • Brooklyn Borough Hall Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itBrooklyn Heights
    Montague & Court Sts · Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
    Tivoli Mushrooms' Instagram · checked Sep 21, 2026
  • CitySeed Wooster Square Farmers Market

    Sometimes has itNew Haven
    511 Chapel St · New Haven
    Seacoast Mushrooms' website · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Columbia Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itMorningside Heights
    Broadway & W. 114th St. · Morningside Heights, Manhattan
    Tivoli Mushrooms' website (Jack: at its Greenmarket stands) · checked Nov 8, 2026
  • Farmers Market at Guilford Fairgrounds

    Sometimes has itGuilford
    111 Lovers Ln · Guilford
    Seacoast Mushrooms' website · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Fort Washington Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itWashington Heights
    168th St. & Ft. Washington Ave. · Washington Heights, Manhattan
    Morgiewicz Produce's Instagram · checked Jun 19, 2026
  • Lincoln Hospital Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itMott Haven
    E. 149th St. bet. Park & Morris Aves · Mott Haven, Bronx
    Morgiewicz Produce's Instagram · checked Jun 19, 2026
  • Ramsey Farmers' Market

    Sometimes has itRamsey
    Ramsey Train Station, 2 W Main St · Ramsey
    Tivoli Mushrooms's own listing · checked Nov 14, 2026
  • Ruppert Park Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itUpper East Side
    90th Street & 2nd Avenue · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Tivoli Mushrooms' Instagram · checked Sep 21, 2026
  • Stonington Village Farmers Market

    Sometimes has itStonington
    22 Bayview Ave · Stonington
    Seacoast Mushrooms' website · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Tribeca Greenmarket

    Sometimes has itTribeca
    Greenwich & Chambers Sts. · Tribeca, Manhattan
    Tivoli Mushrooms' Instagram · checked Sep 21, 2026
  • West Windsor Community Farmers Market

    Sometimes has itPrinceton Junction
    Vaughn Dr parking lot, Princeton Junction station · Princeton Junction
    Noble Mushrooms's vendor profile, West Windsor Community Farmers' Market (2026) · checked Nov 6, 2026
  • Westport Farmers' Market

    Sometimes has itWestport
    7 Sylvan Ln (Gilbertie's Herbs & Gardens) · Westport
    Seacoast Mushrooms' website · checked Nov 11, 2026
  • 79th Street Greenmarket

    Might have itUpper West Side
    79th St. & Columbus Ave. · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Big Apple Fungi (formerly My Shrooms) on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Carroll Gardens Greenmarket

    Might have itCarroll Gardens
    Smith & Carroll Sts · Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
    Big Apple Fungi (formerly My Shrooms) on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Dag Hammarskjold Greenmarket

    Might have itMidtown
    E 47th St & 2nd Ave · Midtown, Manhattan
    Big Apple Fungi (formerly My Shrooms) on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Fferins of Brooklyn

    Might have itPark Slope
    438 7th Ave · Park Slope, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 102nd St

    Might have itCorona
    41-25 102nd St · Corona, Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 126 Clarke St

    Might have itBrentwood
    126 Clarke St · Brentwood
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 136 Lenox Ave

    Might have itHarlem
    136 Lenox Ave · Harlem, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 163rd St

    Might have itJamaica
    89-45 163rd St · Jamaica, Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 3131 Grand Concourse

    Might have itBedford Park
    3131 Grand Concourse · Bedford Park, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 37 Lenox Ave

    Might have itHarlem
    37 Lenox Ave · Harlem, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 37 Lenox Ave

    Might have itHarlem
    37-41 Lenox Ave · Harlem, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 41st Ave

    Might have itCourt Square
    10-07 41st Ave · Court Square, Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 426 33rd St

    Might have itUnion City
    426 33rd St · Union City
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 4725 White Plains Rd

    Might have itWakefield
    4725 White Plains Rd · Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 4776 Broadway

    Might have itInwood
    4776 Broadway · Inwood, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 601 4th St

    Might have itUnion City
    601 4th St · Union City
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 700 Suffolk Ave

    Might have itBrentwood
    700 Suffolk Ave · Brentwood
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare 708 E Tremont Ave

    Might have itEast Tremont
    708 E Tremont Ave · East Tremont, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Copiague

    Might have itCopiague
    870 Merrick Rd · Copiague
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare E 167th St

    Might have itHigh Bridge
    59 E 167th St · High Bridge, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare E Gun Hill Rd

    Might have itNorwood
    320 E Gun Hill Rd · Norwood, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare E Mount Eden Ave

    Might have itTremont
    49 E Mount Eden Ave · Tremont, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Eastchester Rd

    Might have itBaychester
    3040 Eastchester Rd · Baychester, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Farmers Blvd

    Might have itSpringfield Gardens
    145-44 Farmers Blvd · Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Farmingville

    Might have itFarmingville
    379 Horseblock Rd · Farmingville
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Flatbush Ave

    Might have itEast Flatbush
    1498 Flatbush Ave · East Flatbush, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Frederick Douglass Blvd

    Might have itHamilton Heights
    2927 Frederick Douglass Blvd · Hamilton Heights, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Hollis Ave

    Might have itSt. Albans
    199-11 Hollis Ave · St. Albans, Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Jamaica Ave

    Might have itBrooklyn Manor
    90-01 Jamaica Ave · Brooklyn Manor, Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Kingston Ave

    Might have itCrown Heights
    261 Kingston Ave · Crown Heights, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Lincoln Ave

    Might have itEast New York
    675 Lincoln Ave · East New York, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Livonia Ave

    Might have itEast New York
    602 Livonia Ave · East New York, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Mermaid Ave

    Might have itConey Island
    2901 Mermaid Ave · Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Merrick Blvd

    Might have itJamaica
    108-30 Merrick Blvd · Jamaica, Queens
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Metropolitan Ave

    Might have itParkchester
    1654 Metropolitan Ave · Parkchester, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Myrtle Ave

    Might have itBushwick
    1305 Myrtle Ave · Bushwick, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Riverhead

    Might have itRiverhead
    1088 Old Country Rd · Riverhead
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Saratoga Ave

    Might have itBrownsville
    783 Saratoga Ave · Brownsville, Brooklyn
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Somerset

    Might have itSomerset
    621 Hamilton St · Somerset
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare W 135th St

    Might have itHarlem
    24 W 135th St · Harlem, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Webster Ave

    Might have itFordham
    2645 Webster Ave · Fordham, Bronx
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Westbury

    Might have itWestbury
    595 Old Country Rd · Westbury
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fine Fare Yonkers

    Might have itYonkers
    230 S Broadway · Yonkers
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Forest Hills Greenmarket

    Might have itForest Hills
    Queens Blvd. & 70th Ave. · Forest Hills, Queens
    Mushroom Queens on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Greenmarket at MoMA PS1

    Might have itLong Island City
    Jackson Ave & 46th Ave · Long Island City, Queens
    Mushroom Queens on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Madison Farmers Market

    Might have itMadison
    26 Meeting House Ln · Madison
    Madison CT Farmers Market vendor list names Seacoast Mushrooms; varieties from Greenwich Free Press (Jul 2019) · checked Nov 6, 2026
  • Shop Fair St Nicholas Ave

    Might have itWashington Heights
    1617 St Nicholas Ave · Washington Heights, Manhattan
    In Fine Fare's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Sunnyside Greenmarket

    Might have itSunnyside
    Skillman Ave. & 43rd St. · Sunnyside, Queens
    Big Apple Fungi (formerly My Shrooms) on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Tompkins Square Greenmarket

    Might have itEast Village
    7th St. & Avenue A · East Village, Manhattan
    Mushroom Queens on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Tucker Square Greenmarket

    Might have itUpper West Side
    66th St. & Broadway · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Big Apple Fungi (formerly My Shrooms) on GrowNYC's vendor list (not confirmed) · checked Nov 5, 2026
  • Union Square Greenmarket

    Might have itGramercy
    Union Square Park, north and west plazas · Gramercy, Manhattan
    Research pass Nov 2026: NYC Food Policy Center interview · checked Nov 18, 2026

Might also be at 31 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).

Get it delivered

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there