
Herbs & fresh produce
Stores that usually have Blue oyster mushrooms: Austin Organic Market (Forest Hills, Queens), Basil Bandwagon Natural Market (Clinton, NJ), Brooklyn Harvest Market (Williamsburg, Brooklyn) and 21 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 15 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
Oyster mushrooms with steel-blue caps that fade to gray, meaty and mild, sautéed or roasted.
Also sold as blue oyster.
Substitute oyster mushrooms or cremini mushrooms.
Might also be at 31 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).