
Spices & seasonings
Stores that usually have Allspice: 3 Guys From Brooklyn (Dyker Heights, Brooklyn), 99 Ranch Market Edison (Edison, NJ), A Matter of Health (Nanuet, NY) and 2181 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 54 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
The dried berry of a Caribbean tree, tasting like a mix of cloves, cinnamon and nutmeg, used in jerk seasoning, baking and pickling.
Also sold as pimento, jamaica pepper, pimienta de jamaica, pimienta gorda, pimenta da jamaica, yenibahar.
In Caribbean, Levantine and Jamaican cooking.
Substitute cinnamon with cloves or nutmeg.
Might also be at 315 more stores, not confirmed (a guess from the kind of store).