The Pantry Atlas List Saved
← Back to the index
Alligator meat

Meat, eggs & dairy

Alligator meat

Stores that usually have Alligator meat: Big Catch Seafood (Mount Holly, NJ), Butcher's Corner (Florida, NY), Fairway 2131 Broadway (Upper West Side, Manhattan) and 12 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 6 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.

Mild, firm white meat from farmed alligator, mostly tail, often compared to chicken; fried, blackened, or in Cajun sausage.

Also sold as alligator, gator meat, alligator tail.

All kindsTail meat13Sausage13

In Cajun & Creole cooking.

Substitute chicken breast or pork loin.

Where to find it24 stores

  • Big Catch Seafood

    Usually has itTail meatMount Holly
    132 Hulme St · Mount Holly
    Big Catch Seafood's online shop, in stock · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Butcher's Corner

    Usually has itTail meatFlorida
    8a S Main St · Florida
    Butcher's Corner's website menu, listed · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Deluxe Food Market

    Usually has itTail meatChinatown
    79 Elizabeth St · Chinatown, Manhattan
    Deluxe Food Market's Yelp photos
  • Fairway 2131 Broadway

    Usually has itSausageUpper West Side
    2131 Broadway · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 240 E 86th St

    Usually has itSausageUpper East Side
    240 E 86th St · Upper East Side, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 550 2nd Ave

    Usually has itSausageKips Bay
    550 2nd Ave · Kips Bay, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Fairway 766 6th Ave

    Usually has itSausageFlatiron District
    766 6th Ave · Flatiron District, Manhattan
    Stocked at most Fairway branches; this branch not checked
  • Fossil Farms Market and Kitchen

    Usually has itTail meatBoonton
    81 Fulton St · Boonton
    Fossil Farms Market and Kitchen's website · checked Nov 14, 2026
  • Gourmet Garage Hudson St

    Usually has itSausageWest Village
    585 Hudson St · West Village, Manhattan
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Highland Park Market Farmington

    Usually has itSausageFarmington
    204 Main St · Farmington
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Highland Park Market Glastonbury

    Usually has itSausageGlastonbury
    1320 Manchester Rd · Glastonbury
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Highland Park Market Manchester

    Usually has itSausageManchester
    317 Highland St · Manchester
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Paisanos Meat Market

    Usually has itTail meat · SausageBoerum Hill
    162 Smith St · Boerum Hill, Brooklyn
    Reported by a shopper · checked Oct 20, 2026
  • S. Ottomanelli & Sons

    Usually has itTail meat · SausageWoodside
    60-15 Woodside Ave · Woodside, Queens
    Reported by a shopper · checked Oct 20, 2026
  • Wild Fork East Hanover

    Usually has itTail meatEast Hanover
    233 Route 10 · East Hanover
    Instacart, listed at this branch · checked Nov 14, 2026
  • Ottomanelli & Sons Meat Market

    Sometimes has itTail meatWest Village
    285 Bleecker St · West Village, Manhattan
    New York Lifestyles Magazine (Nov 2020) · checked Nov 1, 2020
  • Wild Fork Eatontown

    Sometimes has itTail meatEatontown
    151 Route 35 · Eatontown
    Greater Long Island (Dec 2024), on Wild Fork's range · checked Dec 12, 2024
  • Wild Fork Lake Grove

    Sometimes has itTail meatLake Grove
    2027 Smith Haven Plz · Lake Grove
    Greater Long Island (Dec 2024), on Wild Fork's range · checked Dec 12, 2024
  • Wild Fork Paramus

    Sometimes has itTail meatParamus
    723 Nj-17 · Paramus
    Greater Long Island (Dec 2024), on Wild Fork's range · checked Dec 12, 2024
  • Wild Fork Plainview

    Sometimes has itTail meatPlainview
    409 S Oysterbay Rd · Plainview
    Greater Long Island (Dec 2024), on Wild Fork's range · checked Dec 12, 2024
  • Wild Fork West Hempstead

    Sometimes has itTail meatWest Hempstead
    603 Hempsted Tpke · West Hempstead
    Greater Long Island (Dec 2024), on Wild Fork's range · checked Dec 12, 2024
  • Gourmet Garage

    Might have itSausageTribeca
    366 Broadway · Tribeca, Manhattan
    In Gourmet Garage's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Gourmet Garage W 66th St

    Might have itSausageUpper West Side
    155 W 66th St · Upper West Side, Manhattan
    In Gourmet Garage's Instacart catalog; branch not known · checked Nov 21, 2026
  • Nick's Meat Depot

    Might have itSausageEdison
    1028 Amboy Ave · Edison
    aol.com · checked Nov 7, 2026

Brands spotted1

Key
Usually has itSometimesMightUnconfirmedChecked, not there