
Meat, eggs & dairy
Stores that usually have Alligator meat: Big Catch Seafood (Mount Holly, NJ), Butcher's Corner (Florida, NY), Fairway 2131 Broadway (Upper West Side, Manhattan) and 12 more stores. Sometimes in stock at 6 more stores. Last checked Nov 21, 2026.
Mild, firm white meat from farmed alligator, mostly tail, often compared to chicken; fried, blackened, or in Cajun sausage.
Also sold as alligator, gator meat, alligator tail.
In Cajun & Creole cooking.
Substitute chicken breast or pork loin.